Better Resume, Shane or Floyd?

[AFighter4U]

It depends on which fan you are asking i guess..

[cooper5]

I think Mosley does even if Mayweather beats him.

[wazaa.]

About even. If Mosley hadnt beaten Margarito I would say that Floyds resume was better. Remember, losses count too.

[-Lowkey-]

mosley could go through mayweathers resume with his 0 intact but could floyd go through mosleys resume and keep his 0? Personally I don’t think he could and I think mosley has beaten the better fighters

so yeah mosleys resume is alot better

[Junito-Rulez]

Shane Mosley has the better names on his resume, better wins over DLH, Margarito.
Floyd if he beats Mosley, has the better resume coz a win over Mosley is better than anything Mosley has done; lol. Mosley couldn't beat himself.

[Pugilistic™]

Mosley has fought the better level of competition throughout his career but i give Floyd the advantage when it comes to resume.

[Suckmedry]

Overall level of competition: Shane takes it here

But overall resume, which encompasses wins, losses and the level of fighters....Very even.

Damn. Very close.

[Walt Liquor]

Overall level of competition: Shane takes it here

But overall resume, which encompasses wins, losses and the level of fighters....Very even.

Damn. Very close.

u know what. i agree with this post, iearlier I said shane by a wide margin, but I really think it's shane by a very close margin.

my 3 critera- level of comp (advantage shane), wins (advantage floyd), fighter level/point in their career/weight class/intangibles- small advantage shane.

if either guy wins this fight and beats pac, we are talking about modern greatest resume arguments being made

[V.WEBB]

floyd uses xylocaine all the time.........

That equals cheating?

[steeluv]

Floyds is deceptionally better, but if Floyd had fought De La Hoya the first time when mosely did and Winky and Forest I cant see him winning any 1 of those fights