if oscar is an atg..then isnt judah aswell??

[minasyan]

why does oscar get ****ted on and others like evander holyfield are respected?

[-Huey-]

Oscar beat Pernel Whitaker
beat Julio Cesar Chavez


that's 2 ATG's


Beat Vargas
Beat Mosley
Beat Trinidad

That's HOF'ers

Beat Ike Quartey, Molina, Ruelas,Camacho, Carr, and many other very good fighters.

Who has Judah beat? Spinks? Doesn't even compare

End of thread, P.S. Larry you are washed up and past your prime, time to hang it up homie (the keyboard)

[MurderDeathKill]

De la Hoya did have some good wins but he gets overrated as hell based on overall titles won and drawing power.

[Dan...]

LOL.

What a ******ed thread!

Oscar beat the likes of Chavez, Quartey, Vargas, Whitaker in addition to a host of top contenders. He also had very very close and controversial defeats against great fighters in Tito Trinidad and Shane Mosley.

Who has Zab beaten?

******ed thread - one of the worst I have seen in a while.

[P.WILL]

Oscar beat Pernel Whitaker
beat Julio Cesar Chavez


that's 2 ATG's


Beat Vargas
Beat Mosley
Beat Trinidad

That's HOF'ers

Beat Ike Quartey, Molina, Camacho, Carr, and many other very good fighters.

Who has Judah beat? Spinks? Doesn't even compare

Good post.

[BoxerDood]

Even as a Judah fan, I find this thread foolish. Oscar's losses were all to ATG fighters, and his only KO loss was to someone much bigger than he is, unless you count the Pacquiao RTD where he was zombified, shot, washed up, etc. He also has victories over ATGs like Sweet Pea, Mosley and JCC, along with good fighters like Gatti and Quartey. He's also held the record of world titles in 6 different divisions before Pacquiao broke it last year.

Judah on the other hand blew every opportunity he had, never trained, had no discipline and had a poor trainer. That was the reason why he lost to Tszyu, Baldomir, Clottey and maybe Cotto. He also has ridiculously long layoffs and wasted a majority of his prime years slacking. His only good wins are against Witter, Ward and Spinks. That is like 7% of Oscar's resume. Pernell Whittaker would school all three in one month.

[Danny Gunz]

oscar is not an all time great.

[TBear]

Oscar beat Pernel Whitaker
beat Julio Cesar Chavez


that's 2 ATG's


Beat Vargas
Beat Mosley
Beat Trinidad

That's HOF'ers

Beat Ike Quartey, Molina, Camacho, Carr, and many other very good fighters.

Who has Judah beat? Spinks? Doesn't even compare

That is right!

[baracuda]

does judah have a win over guys like sweetpea or chavez?.....

[-Huey-]

oscar is not an all time great.

No he isn't, the guy in your sig is though...****!