I honestly belive that Shane could have made it through Floyd resume undefeated......

[-GDS-]

Hey Dempsey Floyd is a small guy but Shane is not that bigger then him.People always make a fuss about size but Shane has been the smaller man in most of his fights in recent yrs No?Think about it Forest winky Margas even his bout to raul Marquez I believe was his name.Mosley was never really the bigger man even on May 1 he will be just a lil bigger not by alot.

Shane's is only a little taller, but he's bigger and significantly stonger than Floyd. If Floyd had Shane's extra size, reach, and strength, I pick him to go though Shane's resume undefeated, and I'd also pick him to beat Martinez and Pwill at 154, and maybe Pavlik and Martinez at 160. The reason why I'm hesistant to pick May over guys like Winky, Forrest, Martinez, ect. is because I'm not sure if Floyd would be too small and weak to get their respect.

[BoxerDood]

De La Hoya from 2007 could beat Shane from 2007.

But aside from that, he pretty much destroys everyone aside from Castillo, but he'd still beat him. Mosley is a much bigger fighter than Floyd. These would all be mismatches.

[tjose385]

Shane's is only a little taller, but he's bigger and significantly stonger than Floyd. If Floyd had Shane's extra size, reach, and strength, I pick him to go though Shane's resume undefeated, and I'd also pick him to beat Martinez and Pwill at 154, and maybe Pavlik and Martinez at 160. The reason why I'm hesistant to pick May over guys like Winky, Forrest, Martinez, ect. is because I'm not sure if Floyd would be too small and weak to get their respect.

I'm not trying to hear this bs. FLOYD FOUGHT AT 154 B4, MEANING HE SHOULD HAVE BEEN ABLE TO FIGHT WINKY, FORREST, AND PWILL AT 154. if pac can come from 122 and fight cotto and clottey......then pbf can fight wink, forrest, and pwill

[Kagami Taiga]

I'm not trying to hear this bs. FLOYD FOUGHT AT 154 B4, MEANING HE SHOULD HAVE BEEN ABLE TO FIGHT WINKY, FORREST, AND PWILL AT 154. if pac can come from 122 and fight cotto and clottey......then pbf can fight wink, forrest, and pwill

dude, u do realize ur making no sense rite. floyd fought once at 154 and he had a hard time maintaining the weight. he does not belong at 154. those guys are just too big 4 him. manny would never do good moving up to 154, floyd is a little bigger than he is, but once you get to those middle weights, u start giving up a lot of strength. so much so that it doesnt even make sense. did u see the strength mosely gave up to winks at 154??now imagine mayweather. shane is a lot bigger than may.

nyways, u wanna blame mayweather for not fighting guys at 147 thats one thing, but 154 would be brave on his part, but he has way too much to lose to justify such a ****** risk.

[-EX-]

I think Floyd would beat everyone from Shane's resume...only Vernon Forrest would present a lotta difficulty IMO...

[-Spinal-]

Mosley was a bodybuilder in high school...He was too big for 135, that was not his natural weight class. He should have start at 140, I don't know what he was doing at 135. This is a guy who fought at 154 and when he lost it was decisions and when he won he got like 3 KO's out of 3 wins in that weight class. Forget about 130. Let alone dominating 130 like Floyd did.

But yeah, from 135 to 154 vs the fighters Floyd fought, Shane stays undefeated. Then again, you're comparing a guy who fought the bulk of his KO's at 130 to a guy who has 3 KO wins at 154.

[baracuda]

I think Floyd would beat everyone from Shane's resume...only Vernon Forrest would present a lotta difficulty IMO...

winky?...cotto?.....

[BoxerDood]

Floyd won a SD over Oscar at 154. Should have been unanimous.
Shane won a UD over Oscar at 154. He should have lost a UD.

I also don't know about a young Shane beating Genaro Hernandez or Diego Corrales at SFW.

If I remember correctly, Shane beat Genaro in the amateurs. Not saying that would be the same outcome in the pros, but it wasn't close at all from what I remember.

[-Spinal-]

I think Floyd would beat everyone from Shane's resume...only Vernon Forrest would present a lotta difficulty IMO...

Yup, and Winky Wright too. That's about it. The 2007 DLH at 154 would have present problems to a 2007 Mosley who lost to Cotto later in that same year. I also think the 2006 Zab would have won more rounds against Mosley than he did against Floyd. 2002 prime Castillo(before the big fight against Corrales) was a tough fight for anybody, idc who they were.

[-Spinal-]

winky?...cotto?.....

Yes...and no.....