I honestly belive that Shane could have made it through Floyd resume undefeated......

[-Hyperion-]

135 and up ****ing esily , hell p4p, he ****s corrales, chicanito,chavez and manfredy too......and he would have done it more decisively....

[Michael Hall]

I don't think so really, He's not THAT much smaller. It just seems like Mayweather hadn't grown into the welterweight frame at the time.

He is definately a welterweight now, theres no way Floyd could make JR. WW without being weight drained (which is why he couldn't make the 144 catchweight against Marquez)

Shane moved up to 154 when he probably could have stayed at 147 for the majority of his career (seeing as he did move back down to 147 at 37 years old)

Floyd is a legit WW now. He's finally grown into the weight class. When Mosley was fighting at 139 in the amateurs, Floyd was fighting at 126. Think about it... There is a natural size advantage for Mosley.

[Mr. Fantastic]

Oscar would of rapped everyone Floyd has faced too.

This is what's messed up. Lot of greatness is chosen based on who they choose to avoid and get away with it. That's what I see.

[Rome-By-Ko]

Shane skipped 140 and straight to 147. He had trouble making 135 when he fought John Brown

He skip 140 because oscar Boxing cash cow was at WW.It was not because he could not make 140 remember he was a small for years.

[DLT]

Oscar would of rapped everyone Floyd has faced too.

This is what's messed up. Lot of greatness is chosen based on who they choose to avoid and get away with it. That's what I see.

Dude, do you know that Oscar actually lost to Floyd? Dont act like that didnt happened or make excuses for that but then try to go the opposite way when it suits you. Oscar also had a ton of gift decisions in his career in fights people think he actually lost so lets not act like he was Roy Jones or something. He was also a 5'11 130 pounder beating up on smaller guys all the time, just like he again tried to do to Pac and got his ass lit up

[DLT]

He skip 140 because oscar Boxing cash cow was at WW.It was not because he could not make 140 remember he was a small for years.

IDK about that. It wasnt too long after that he then went to 154 and said that he cant make WW anymore no matter what. Ofcourse he did but obviously he changed he way he was doing something because he was emphatic that he cant make WW again

[Mr. Fantastic]

Dude, do you know that Oscar actually lost to Floyd? Dont act like that didnt happened or make excuses for that but then try to go the opposite way when it suits you. Oscar also had a ton of gift decisions in his career in fights people think he actually lost so lets not act like he was Roy Jones or something. He was also a 5'11 130 pounder beating up on smaller guys all the time, just like he again tried to do to Pac and got his ass lit up

Prime DLH would of beaten Floyd.

Smaller guys all the time?? Is that why he is a 6 division world champ?? lol
You're right he isn't Roy Jones. He actually fought people that weren't policemen.

[Rome-By-Ko]

Thats a flawed statement because Shane is a bigger man than Floyd which means he is fighting all smaller guys. Floyd fought alot of guys who were bigger than him but they would be all smaller than Shane. Thats like saying Floyd would be undefeated with Pac's, EM's, MAB's, and JMM resume

Once again this is flawed.May was at 130 right Shane was the bigger name right.they would move up and get creamed by shane at lightweight.simple at 140 no one stood a chance sorry there's not one person on floyds resume who has a chance.
once

[V.WEBB]

He skip 140 because oscar Boxing cash cow was at WW.It was not because he could not make 140 remember he was a small for years.

Shane was having trouble making 135, so much so that he went all the way up to fight at 147, in addition to cashing out fighting Oscar in a BIG fight. It was evident that he couldn't make 35 because Arum wanted him to fight Mayweather at a catch-weight of 137 lbs.

[Roy Keane]

yep he would be 40-0 with 39 ko's only person hes not KOING is oscar possibly baldomir