If Shane beats Floyd, where do you rank him all-time?

[-EX-]

B
u
m
p
...

[jrosales13]

I still think that even if Shane beats Floyd. That I would not rank him ahead of Floyd...

I mean from top to bottom, body of work Floyd resume is better.

[gibo]

If Shane beats Floyd????? It ain't happening!!! So where would you rank Shane after this defeat?

[STRUGG]

ko....or controversial decision?.............................

[Haterfree]

I agree with you on the rematch part. Floyd is gonna find himself in a real bind if he convincingly beats Mosley to a point where a rematch isn't warrented. There isn't anyone left for him to fight aside Pac, and if Pac doesn't accept Mayweather's OST demands I don't know what he'd do.

Mayweather could go make big fights with Berto, Cotto, Khan, even Spinks if he wants to. Floyd did good PPV numbers fighting Carlos Baldomir & that is a small miracle.

[trk]

I still think that even if Shane beats Floyd. That I would not rank him ahead of Floyd...

I mean from top to bottom, body of work Floyd resume is better.

I agree. Floyd's resume is underrated by a lot of people.

I have Shane outside the top 50 right now. A win over Floyd could maybe move him into the 40-50 range.