My top 100 P4P!

[Guest]

Joking aside, I have to agree with Nige here. Surely a p4p list shouldn't reflect how great a boxer was but how great they are right now? Otherwise Roy Jones would still be heading the list like he did for most of the last ten years (according to The Ring at least...)

And with this principle, triangular logic can't have that much of an effect. A loss to one guy can't blot out six wins to others (hypothetically speaking) when the guy that beat the guy has lost all his others. (I hope someone's following that, I confused myself).


That said... John Ruiz???

[Truth]

Nice work, on the list....

[NiGe2011]

Okay, here is the recently updated list. Bold indicates a large change in position or a debut. And yes, I do have too much free time on my hands.

Top 100 P4P:

(1) Bernard Hopkins
(2) Winky Wright
(3) Floyd Mayweather Jr
(4) Marco Antonio Barrera
(5) Erik Morales
(6) Diego Corrales
(7) Jose Luis Castillo
(8) Manny Pacquiao
(9) Zab Judah
(10) Rafeal Marquez
(11) Ricky Hatton (+32)
(12) Kostya Tszyu (-9)
(13) Juan Manuel Marquez
(14) Glen Johnson
(15) Kassim Ouma
(16) Antonio Tarver
(17) Antonio Margarito
(18) Jesus Chavez
(19) Jean Marc Mormeck
(20) Martin Castillo
(21) Joel Casamayor
(22) Shane Mosley
(22) Jorge Arce
(23) Cory Spinks
(24) Felix Sturm
(25) Joe Calzaghe
(26) James Toney
(27) Oscar Larios
(28) Pongsaklek Wonjongkam
(29) Vivian Harris
(30) Fernando Montiel
(31) Vitali Klistschko
(32) Ricardo Mayorga
(33) Vernon Forrest
(34) Hozumi Hasegawa
(35) Acelino Freitas
(36) Chris Byrd
(37) Miguel Cotto
(38) Jermain Taylor
(39) Oscar De La Hoya
(40) Arturo Gatti
(41) Rosendo Alvarez
(42) Lorezno Parra
(43) Jeff Lacy
(44) Juan Diaz
(45) Injin Chi
(46) Juan Lazcano
(47) Rocky Juarez
(48) Julio Diaz (+9)
(49) Jose Burgos
(50) Ivan Calderon
(51) Lamon Brewster
(51) Wayne Braithwaite
(52) Fernando Vargas
(53) Javier Castillejo
(54) Ivan Calderon
(55) Daniel Santos
(56) Joan Guzman
(57) Carlos Hernandez
(58) Luis Perez
(59) Yutaka Niida
(60) John Ruiz
(61) Verno Phillips
(62) O’Neil Bell
(63) Scott Harrison (debut)
(64) Oktay Urkal
(65) Jose Navarro
(66) Veeraphol Sahaprom
(67) Israel Vazquez
(68) Julio Gonzalez
(69) Fabrice Tiozzo
(70) Junior Witter
(71) Hasim Rahman
(72) Travis Simms
(73) Clinton Woods
(74) Tomasz Adamek (debut)
(75) Sharmba Mitchell
(76) Sam Soliman
(77) Kingsley Ikeke
(78) Chris John
(79) Mikkel Kessler
(80) Zsolt Erdei
(81) Monte Barrett
(82) Robin Reid
(83) Zaheer Rahim
(84) Hussein Hussein
(85) Vincente Mosquera
(86) Kid Diamond
(87) Howard Eastman
(88) Demarcus Corley
(89) Kermit Cintron
(90) Kendall Holt
(91) Dale Brown
(92) Raymond Joval
(93) Yodsan 3K Battery
(94) Johnny Nelson
(95) Samuel Peter
(97) Robbie Peden
(98) Carlos Baldomir (debut)
(99) Calvin Brock
(100) Robert Guerrero

Gone from list: Paul Briggs, Felix Trinidad (due to retirement), Omar Sheika

[Exciterx30]

Okay, here is the recently updated list. Bold indicates a large change in position or a debut. And yes, I do have too much free time on my hands.

Top 100 P4P:

(1) Bernard Hopkins
(2) Winky Wright
(3) Floyd Mayweather Jr
(4) Marco Antonio Barrera
(5) Erik Morales
(6) Diego Corrales
(7) Jose Luis Castillo
(8) Manny Pacquiao
(9) Zab Judah
(10) Rafeal Marquez
(11) Ricky Hatton (+32)
(12) Kostya Tszyu (-9)
(13) Juan Manuel Marquez
(14) Glen Johnson
(15) Kassim Ouma
(16) Antonio Tarver
(17) Antonio Margarito
(18) Jesus Chavez
(19) Jean Marc Mormeck
(20) Martin Castillo
(21) Joel Casamayor
(22) Shane Mosley
(22) Jorge Arce
(23) Cory Spinks
(24) Felix Sturm
(25) Joe Calzaghe
(26) James Toney
(27) Oscar Larios
(28) Pongsaklek Wonjongkam
(29) Vivian Harris
(30) Fernando Montiel
(31) Vitali Klistschko
(32) Ricardo Mayorga
(33) Vernon Forrest
(34) Hozumi Hasegawa
(35) Acelino Freitas
(36) Chris Byrd
(37) Miguel Cotto
(38) Jermain Taylor
(39) Oscar De La Hoya
(40) Arturo Gatti
(41) Rosendo Alvarez
(42) Lorezno Parra
(43) Jeff Lacy
(44) Juan Diaz
(45) Injin Chi
(46) Juan Lazcano
(47) Rocky Juarez
(48) Julio Diaz (+9)
(49) Jose Burgos
(50) Ivan Calderon
(51) Lamon Brewster
(51) Wayne Braithwaite
(52) Fernando Vargas
(53) Javier Castillejo
(54) Ivan Calderon
(55) Daniel Santos
(56) Joan Guzman
(57) Carlos Hernandez
(58) Luis Perez
(59) Yutaka Niida
(60) John Ruiz
(61) Verno Phillips
(62) O’Neil Bell
(63) Scott Harrison (debut)
(64) Oktay Urkal
(65) Jose Navarro
(66) Veeraphol Sahaprom
(67) Israel Vazquez
(68) Julio Gonzalez
(69) Fabrice Tiozzo
(70) Junior Witter
(71) Hasim Rahman
(72) Travis Simms
(73) Clinton Woods
(74) Tomasz Adamek (debut)
(75) Sharmba Mitchell
(76) Sam Soliman
(77) Kingsley Ikeke
(78) Chris John
(79) Mikkel Kessler
(80) Zsolt Erdei
(81) Monte Barrett
(82) Robin Reid
(83) Zaheer Rahim
(84) Hussein Hussein
(85) Vincente Mosquera
(86) Kid Diamond
(87) Howard Eastman
(88) Demarcus Corley
(89) Kermit Cintron
(90) Kendall Holt
(91) Dale Brown
(92) Raymond Joval
(93) Yodsan 3K Battery
(94) Johnny Nelson
(95) Samuel Peter
(97) Robbie Peden
(98) Carlos Baldomir (debut)
(99) Calvin Brock
(100) Robert Guerrero

Gone from list: Paul Briggs, Felix Trinidad (due to retirement), Omar Sheika

Good that Trinidad is not on the list anymore. I did not agree with the ranking you gave him. It's better now.

[NiGe2011]

Good that Trinidad is not on the list anymore. I did not agree with the ranking you gave him. It's better now.

Yeah, it is really looking like he is not coming back this time... So away he goes.

[NiGe2011]

Oh my my my, how a little time can change things...

[Mick Hucknall]

yeh at this point in time, Sturm,Johnson,Judah,Morales etc above Calzaghe would be a piss take

[eazy_mas]

Ivan Calderon is 54?!?!??!

i think the guy could be top 10 if not 5

[me2007]

thats the worst p4p list i`ve ever read...

[SHB]

Wow.

I mean, wow.