Most overrated American fighter of the decade?

[pbftxrs316]

get the **** out of here----first of all chico was rated number 3 p4p when floyd fought him and was chosen to overwhelm floyd with his power and floyd made him land in single digits every round---name any other fighter who has done this against another undefeated fighter---and gatti was the wbc champion when he fought floyd and ended up winning the wbc ww title the next year, what does that say about how great gatti was----hatton had a 0---jlc was a rugged fighter who gave floyd 2 good fights----and floyd won the linear ww title from baldomir, who was the champion of the division at the time--meaning he was ranked as champion, and floyd dominated a guy who outweighed him by 13 pounds----oscar was the wbc jmw champion and made floyd basically give up every advantage floyd had on him except skills----floyd was dancing with the stars when he getting ready for the hatton fight and he dominated hatton still, fighting hatton's fight and knocked him out----i mean pac fought hatton and oscar-----

floyd beat a guy who had 30 ko's in 32 fights in n'dou---i mean in no ****ing way is this kid overrated---he is not only the most complext fighter on the list, the most skilled fighter on the list, he is arguably the most technically profficient fighter in boxing history---i've seen them all, and i've never seen a fighter who put everything together as well as floyd----he isn't undefeated for no reason---he has dominated in his career for the most part---and made it look too easy---that's why he gets called brilliant when he fights, because people know as much as they see him as a boring fighter, he is as close to perfection in the ring as it comes----

[BillyBoxing]

why isnt oscar on the list??

off your list though, jermain taylor

Tarver bra!!!

Ask who is the better one to Bernard.
Undefeated Taylor is better than Antonio.

The guy get dropped by Bernard.It says a lot.
He looked almost ****tier than Pavlik against Nard,and he is a natural LHW.


Tarver would have been koed by a prime Roy.
That guy is a joke,and talk ****.

[BillyBoxing]

tarver.....................................

Thanks!!!

It's obvious.

Lacy is the worst but he isn't on the list...

[BillyBoxing]

Thanks!!!

It's obvious.

Lacy is the worst but he isn't on the list...

Antonio joker.lol

[fabie]

Floyd Mayweather is god-like in his superlative skills only to be doubted with his carefully-picked opponents...

I wish there is a way to really test his awesome skills and in this light I can say, that he is overrated. Doesn't mean that I am a hater but in fact a fan of his skills.

Easily could be one of the best ever.....if and only if his opponents were really up to par with his skills. He should have taken the biggest and baddest opponents in the WW and perhaps even go up higher in weight level.

I still believe in his skills and that in itself is enigmatic and in a dilemma. I would hope for him to fight Pacquiao and see from there. This upcoming fight with Mosley should have been done long time ago.

But now, I am not even sure if Mosley is the same Mosley of old...the really potent one.

I just wished that Floyd fought his heart out like Muhammad Ali fought all of the greatest in the heavyweight division.....nothing more can be said about Ali, but still the GREATEST OF THEM ALL.

[jaestix1]

the idea of hopkins and mayweather being in an overrated discussion is absurd. most of the list are rated where they should be.

[Ryannn]

floyd mayweather most definitely....

[Easy-E]

I mean think about it like this, its obviously Floyd. He has defeated 14 world championship fighters, more than Manny Pac, Hopkins, Pavilk or anybody. Still though, his resume is ****.
I read it on PacLand, so it MUST be true!

[Ryannn]

I mean think about it like this, its obviously Floyd. He has defeated 14 world championship fighters, more than Manny Pac, Hopkins, Pavilk or anybody. Still though, his resume is ****.
I read it on PacLand, so it MUST be true!

david diaz was a world champion....

this argument sucks balls

[HaglerSteelChin]

Butterbean but it was hard choice.