(No hate thread) Do you consider mayweather one of the best Welterweights of this era

[jrosales13]

So now you see why you're wrong then. The thread said best WW's of this era. Floyd is definetly one of them without a doubt.

I didn't THIS era meant 4yrs. And, how was I wrong either way? I said skill wise he is resume he is not.

Resume wise I would say as of right now. Pac has a better resume than Floyd. Now if Floyd beats Shane that would change.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

It says "This era." I'm gonna start from the year 2000...and I'm not sure he's top 10. Maybe. But def not top 5.

Yeah I dont think hes top 5 either. But hes Top 10 IMO. Not bad for his 4th weight class.

[jrosales13]

It says "This era." I'm gonna start from the year 2000...and I'm not sure he's top 10. Maybe. But def not top 5.

Can you do a top 5 since 2000?

[713832281]

at 147 i do not consider PBF one of the best of this era. he has not done enough.

[jrosales13]

Yeah I dont think hes top 5 either. But hes Top 10 IMO. Not bad for his 4th weight class.

Then you must agree he is not the best WW of this era. Since we going from 2000 and he can't make the top 5 right?

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Tito, Forrest,Oscar, Quartey and Whitakher werent WW's when Floyd was. There is room for him in a Top 10 list.

[badnewsbrown]

obviously one the most talented. but he never proved it against elite competition

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Then you must agree he is not the best WW of this era. Since we going from 2000 and he can't make the top 5 right?

I never said he was the best WW. Floyd didnt hit WW until the middle of the decade.

I wouldnt consider guys like Tito, Nell, Oscar, Quartey and Forrest to be in his era for WW's. Floyds era is guys like Cotto, Marg, Judah, Baldi, Mosley, Pac etc...

[bojangles1987]

Tito, Forrest,Oscar, Quartey and Whitakher werent WW's when Floyd was. There is room for him in a Top 10 list.

But wouldn't this era be the last 10-15 years? All those guys were welterweights in that time frame, and would all be ahead of Floyd.

[Hi-Dro]

Then you must agree he is not the best WW of this era. Since we going from 2000 and he can't make the top 5 right?

Hell Nah he's not the best WW

the question is

is he ONE of the best?