Joe Calzaghe Or Felix Trinidad?

[jrosales13]

The thread title is who is the greater fighter. Is Tito Trinidad and is not even close. Unified WW champ, unified JMW champ, 3 division champ.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

The thread title is who is the greater fighter. Is Tito Trinidad and is not even close. Unified WW champ, unified JMW champ, 3 division champ.

Its been a while since we agreed.....lol.

[street bully]

Calzaghe didn't exactly fight Hopkins and Jones while he was in his prime did he??

Don't give me that crap. Joe was in his prime. he was 36 and just had the best win of his career against Kessler, and phyically hadn't slowed down at all. He looks like ****, and in all ring side scores eyes loses to Hopkins and then all of the sudden he is past it in the tspan of a single fight? He then goes back to his great form against Jones and retires whereas Jones had been shot for five years. Joe was a fighter who hit his prime in his 30s like Hopkins.

[jrosales13]

Pretty even, toss up.

Trinidad fought better fighters by far, Calzaghe was better skilled and didn't lose.

Calzaghe did not have better skills, just cuz you overwhelm guys because you throw over 100 punches does not make you more skilled.

[soyotoyapex]

Where's Soir when joe needs him?

[Mr. Fantastic]

Don't give me that crap. Joe was in his prime. he was 36 and just had the best win of his career against Kessler, and phyically hadn't slowed down at all. Whereas Jones had been shot for five years. Joe was a fighter who hit his prime in his 30s like Hopkins.

@ Joe was in his prime @ 36.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Damn. Tito fans, Hopkins fans, and Calzaghe fans this thread will be epic.

Boxasmash
Bully
Champbox
Jrosales
Samurai
Dirk Diggler UK
Chicano

[Rabbit ♠]

Never been a Trinidad fan at all, so my vote would go to Calzaghe automatically anyway.

Why don't you like Trinidad. The similarities between him and Pacquiao are uncanny (not style wise)

[jrosales13]

Its been a while since we agreed.....lol.

Man I got here late, because you had me messing around in your thread. I let this one slip by...

[IMDAZED]

Gotta go with Trinidad. His run from 1999-2001 was as amazing as I've seen - only topped by Pacquiao's recent run. That secured his legacy.