Joe Calzaghe Or Felix Trinidad?

[CaRnAgEViOLaToR]

Tito......

[danny13]

Tough one.

Calzaghe wins this one for me and I am Puerto Rican. Trinidad is a warrior and will go down in history, but he tainted his legacy with his terrible come backs. I went to the Jones v. Trinidad fight and actually witnessed the beat down.

Calzaghe destroyed Roy. The win over Kessler was a great one. Kessler is a top talent and that was an amazing display by Joe. Joe beat Bika, Lacy when he was undefeated and beat a lot of other great fighters.

Calzaghe...but Trinidad was a beast!

[roxy]

Both have done alot but I think Trinidad has more meaningful wins so between the two, I say Trinidad.

[CaRnAgEViOLaToR]

Calzaghe wins this one for me and I am Puerto Rican. Trinidad is a warrior and will go down in history, but he tainted his legacy with his terrible come backs. I went to the Jones v. Trinidad fight and actually witnessed the beat down.

Calzaghe destroyed Roy. The win over Kessler was a great one. Kessler is a top talent and that was an amazing display by Joe. Joe beat Bika, Lacy when he was undefeated and beat a lot of other great fighters.

Calzaghe...but Trinidad was a beast!

Dude, Tito was old and way above his best weight...Jones vs. Tito was basically a showcase of two old icons. Ala Leonard/Duran III

Tito beat a prime Vargas who was way better than Kessler or Lacy.

[Bright-Eyes]

Calzaghe wins this one for me and I am Puerto Rican. Trinidad is a warrior and will go down in history, but he tainted his legacy with his terrible come backs. I went to the Jones v. Trinidad fight and actually witnessed the beat down.

Calzaghe destroyed Roy. The win over Kessler was a great one. Kessler is a top talent and that was an amazing display by Joe. Joe beat Bika, Lacy when he was undefeated and beat a lot of other great fighters.

Calzaghe...but Trinidad was a beast!

How can you hold the loss to Roy Jones against Tito? Not only was Tito shot and rusty,but he was pudgy several weight classes above his peak weight.Roy was shot to bits and without a win over world class opposition for five years at that point.Lacy wasn't a better fighter than David Reid and Vargas was a better fighter than Kessler.

[Shazam!]

****** poll.

Why can only one be remembered as a great fighter? They both are.

Do you mean who should be regarded more highly? I would say Cazlaghe, because he couldn't have done anymore than he did. Undefeated and a champion for 10 years. That takes incredible ability and application.

Trinidad was awesome though. Mad props to Felix. Definite Hall of Famer.

[DeelDough]

@ Joe was in his prime @ 36.

Well he was undefeated when he retired , so is to say he wasnt???? Common man look at the votes , stop making a fool out ur self

[HitmanHattonAY]

they are both good fighters