Is Floyd Mayweather A ATG?

[Akyra]

LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!

funny thread!!

[PensionKiller]

ok pension....

hatton is not HOF. he was a good champion and beat a hof fighter and retired him. excellent win. at 140, he was a very solid lineal champion. at 147, he wasn't so great.

you say oscar is atg, then you say in the next sentence that he's very good. ATG, are great fighters, no question, not borderliners. Look at oscar's record?????/ He fought the best, but never beat the best. HOF definietly.

Castillo and Corrales are going to be argued and maybe get in, but I doubt they will be first timers, an argument AGAINST them certainly can be made. I love Chico as much as the next guy, but his best win when he fought Floyd was Garcia, he definitely didn't have HOF credentials at the time, and he will probably get in due to the Castillo fight and how he went out.

Oscar is a great fighter for me. He has accomplished a lot. He's fought the best.

I'm a fan of him.

He has fought the best, and didn;t win all, but he also beat some very good to great fighters too.

He beat a legend although not in prime in Chavez.

He lost to Hopkins who is ATG.

He lost to Tito but won it for me.

Whitaker, well he was young in his first fight and lost both perhaps.

Mosely had roids, or is very likely to have had it.

He did lose to Floyd but was out of prime.

He beat Vargas who is a good fighter.

Mayorga again is good.

I think he won a belt VS Sturm too. Although it was close

Quartey lost to him in a good fight.

He beat camacho who is a good fighter

He lost to Manny who is in prime

I believe he is an ATG. I'm not always right but I feel your love bro

It's just my opinion that Oscar is a very good fighter, especially when he was in prime.

Hatton has a case for HOF for me.

[Amazinger]

...........................

of coarse the best there was the best ther will everbwe.
unbeatens beby! others are just **** and none PPV materials

[IMDAZED]

No. Not yet, anyway. Almost.

[project xxx1]

yep he is for me

[Walt Liquor]

No. Not yet, anyway. Almost.

THANK YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

He definitely has the potential to be, but I think "NSB" ATG is much different than real ATG.

[Walt Liquor]

Oscar is a great fighter for me. He has accomplished a lot. He's fought the best.

I'm a fan of him.

He has fought the best, and didn;t win all, but he also beat some very good to great fighters too.

He beat a legend although not in prime in Chavez.

He lost to Hopkins who is ATG.

He lost to Tito but won it for me.

Whitaker, well he was young in his first fight and lost both perhaps.

Mosely had roids, or is very likely to have had it.

He did lose to Floyd but was out of prime.

He beat Vargas who is a good fighter.

Mayorga again is good.

I think he won a belt VS Sturm too. Although it was close

Quartey lost to him in a good fight.

He beat camacho who is a good fighter

He lost to Manny who is in prime

I believe he is an ATG. I'm not always right but I feel your love bro

It's just my opinion that Oscar is a very good fighter, especially when he was in prime.

Hatton has a case for HOF for me.

Hey, that stuff is all in the eye of the beholder and I like talking boxing with you and I certainly ain't trying to talk shi t about your opinion. Oscar has a very impressive resume to me, just stepping up to fight BHOP took huge balls (on par with JMM stepping up to fight Floyd). But he's not ATG in my mind, but definitely first ballot HOF'er and there's no shame in that.

Ricky lost to two first ballot HOF'ers. One, he stepped up to fight, and one took his title. He had a very good career and there are people tha tmade it in the HOF for less. I just don't think he's good enough.

[Alibata]

Floyd is an ATG, but Manny is ranked higher than him. Floyd is ranked in the 40's and Manny is around 20's.

I got it flipped. My bad by higher I meant numerically higher number.

[PensionKiller]

Hey, that stuff is all in the eye of the beholder and I like talking boxing with you and I certainly ain't trying to talk shi t about your opinion. Oscar has a very impressive resume to me, just stepping up to fight BHOP took huge balls (on par with JMM stepping up to fight Floyd). But he's not ATG in my mind, but definitely first ballot HOF'er and there's no shame in that.

Ricky lost to two first ballot HOF'ers. One, he stepped up to fight, and one took his title. He had a very good career and there are people tha tmade it in the HOF for less. I just don't think he's good enough.

I know you're not trying to talk ****, I have a lot of respect for you and your opinion bro

I also understand where you are coming from.

There are less in the HOF for sure.

I agree Oscar is definitely a HOF no doubt. I also believe he's a fierce fighter and in his prime he had a lot of speed, decent power, intangibles etc to beat so many people.

I suppose ATG should not be taken lightly.

As for Hatton, I hear you too. He is a good fighter, but not anywhere near great. Far from it, but he has beaten some good fighters and been a decent champ.

Gotta go now. I like talking boxing with you too. No **** lol

[-Spinal-]

Who was talking about Pacquaio?

Who was talking about Mosley, Corrales, Castillo etc? I mentioned those guys too, why did you only pick Pacquiao out of all the names I mentioned? This is about Mayweather being or not being an ATG and names have to be mentioned Point Blank.