Fighters of the decade by weightclass

[IMDAZED]

What do you mean?

Disputed loss to shane mosley, TKO Gatti, Castillejo, TKO Fernando Vargas, TKO Campas, TKO Mayorga.

That doesn't sound THAT great but looking at the top 10 JM well, #4 sounds about right. (i missed mosley by mistake). Here is the rings top 10 for JW:

1. Winky
2. Trinidad
3. Mosley
4. Oscar
5. Vargas
6. Sergei Dzindziruk
7. Daniel Santos
8. Kassim Ouma
9. Vernon Forrest
10. Cory Spinks

You act like Shane Mosley was some star at 154 so the fact that Oscar lost a disputed decision to him means something. Newsflash, Shane Mosley did next to nothing at 154.

2. The Gatti win meant SQUAT and was at 147, not 154.

3. Castillejo? Didn't I just say don't tell me about some chump he beat for a title?

4. Campas? Campas? Lord, have mercy. Come on NATAS, I thought you followed the sport back then.

[AssasinKing]

Good list....sept id pick cotto over mayweather for WW

[IMDAZED]

Welterweight is easily (like it or not) Antonio Margarito.

[ИATAS]

You act like Shane Mosley was some star at 154 so the fact that Oscar lost a disputed decision to him means something. Newsflash, Shane Mosley did next to nothing at 154.

2. The Gatti win meant SQUAT and was at 147, not 154.

3. Castillejo? Didn't I just say don't tell me about some chump he beat for a title?

4. Campas? Campas? Lord, have mercy. Come on NATAS, I thought you followed the sport back then.

ok, please show me your top ten and where oscar fits in. Thanks

[IMDAZED]

ok, please show me your top ten and where oscar fits in. Thanks

I don't have a top ten for JMW. But I'll do one for every weight class. But the top junior middle for the decade is easily Winky. Hell, I'd put Tito ahead of DLH for 154 for the past decade.

[American Dream]

There has been no dominant fighter at Light heavy since Roy. The division is in a sad state, maybe this decade will be better.

Maybe it has to be Roy because who are the other options? It feels wrong to call Tarver light heavy of the decade on the sole merit of beating a drained and faded version of Roy. Dawson maybe but what has he really done at light heavy except beating Tarver and Johnson, Roy beat Tarver to...

The Morales wins were at 130. Marquez's win over Barrera was as well. Manny spent only a short time at 126; Marquez was consistently near the top of the class from 2000-06. I'd give him the edge as Feather of the decade.



You could make a case for Dawson as well. Johnson and Tarver (X2), Harding, and Adamek were as strong a run as Jones in the 00-03 at 75. I think those two could easily have a case for 1-2, though Tarver is in the mix too because he really had a strong run from 00-04.

bolded...good post

[boxasmash]

Heavyweight: Lewis
Cruiserweight: Haye
Light Heayweight: Jones Jr
Super Middleweight: Calzaghe
Middleweight: Hopkins
Light Middleweight: Wright
Welterweight: Mosley
Jr Welterweight: Hatton
Lightweight: Castillo
Super Featherweight: Pacquiao

[Silencers]

It's really hard to list them all because some divisions were in a state on flux for the past 10 years without a clear leader. Only a few divisions have clear cut guys who were ahead of the pack.

[ИATAS]

I don't have a top ten for JMW. But I'll do one for every weight class. But the top junior middle for the decade is easily Winky. Hell, I'd put Tito ahead of DLH for 154 for the past decade.

tito and winky were ahead of oscar. didn't you see the list I typed out? 1.winky, 2.tito, 3.shane, then 4.oscar.

Look at the top 10 i posted. I don't see how oscar doesn't fit right in the middle of those named fighters.

[IMDAZED]

tito and winky were ahead of oscar. didn't you see the list I typed out? 1.winky, 2.tito, 3.shane, then 4.oscar.

Look at the top 10 i posted. I don't see how oscar doesn't fit right in the middle of those named fighters.

Honestly, you could put a bunch of people ahead of Oscar. Doesn't necessarily mean they're good but they just did more at 154. ****, you could put Kassim Ouma ahead of him. I'd have to sit down and take a look but Shane and Oscar aren't top five at 154. They're just nice names who had their fights showcased.