If Mayweather beats Mosley, Mayweather is P4P KING again

[FLY TY]

lol beating an old past his prime mosley will get him the no.1 spot? lol

may had that spot before he retired.


surely oscar was old and "past prime" when manny beat him. what about cotto and hatton? they weren't in their "primes," when manny beat them.


considering floyd beat oscar and hatton (who was prime at the time) years before manny got to them, and the reason manny got p4p #1 was b/c floyd retired, is it unreasonable to assume mayweather should be considered p4p #1 when he came back? it may be displeasing to pacquiao fans, but unreasonable?

i think not.

[Clint650]

If Floyd walks away without a scratch against Mosley, I'm betting the house against Pac when the time comes.

[oc9979]

***** thinks pacquiao team made cotto come in at 145 where cotto was the one who asked for that weigh. So ****** enough to think mayweather will come at P4P no.1 The only way that could happen is if pacquiao loses. Just some reality check not everything involves with floyd.

Well Cotto was at #7 p4p and Clottey is not anywhere in the p4p list.
While Mosley is 3. Mosley should be #1 welterweight because Cotto was #2 when Pacquiao beat Cotto.

JMM is #5 p4p.

Beating 3 and 2 P4P won't get you to #1


Cotto did not ask for the fight at 145. He agreed to the catch weight because they wanted him to come down 143.

[The Noose]

**** outta here....


this is the bull**** bias i refer to when ppl post **** about manny compared to floyd.


manny's had dangerous opponents his last few fights? have you forgotten that floyd had already beaten 2 of those guys before manny did?

did you also forget that manny and roach think yuri foreman is too big to fight, but you insist floyd should move up and face paul williams, who is waaaay bigger than yuri foreman, in order to prove himself...


floyd fighting the guy, who KO'ed the guy, that beat pacquiao's last 2 opponents is fine with me.

Floyd has been a WW for years and beat Oscar at 154 years ago.

I dont consider SMM a real threat. No one believes he really stands a chance.
In boxing its about style matchup. Not who beat who.

I could just as easily say Oscar beat SMM, and Cotto beat SMM, so Pac KOing Cotto and Oscar makes Floyd taking on SMM pointless.
But thats ovbviously illogical.

All im saying is, when Pac fought Hatton,Oscar and Cotto, many people thought he would lose or get KO'd.

No one thinks SMM will beat Floyd.

[fcastro1]

Pac hasn't been a FW since 2004, that's 6 years ago. 1 year and a half ago he moved up to lightweight to fight David Diaz.

pacs at his 7th weight class spanning 10 divisions and brutally beating these guys. pleez tell me how that is not better than floyd winning a decision at his natural weight.

[BritishBoxing92]

In Mosley, Mayweather will have beaten the no.1 welterweight in the world. Mosley beat Margarito who was considered the no.1 welterweight that time. Margarito beat Cotto who was considered the no.1 welterweight back in time.

Pacquaio still has to beat a 147 lb fighter. I don't rate the win over Cotto as a legit win over a 147 lber because Team Pacquiao made him come in at 145 lbs.

I wanted to add a poll but I'm not going to. This website is being controlled by *******s. Instead, I just want a normal discussion. *******s don't need to reply.

Do you guys agree that Floyd Mayweather Jr makes a case to be P4P KING again or should Manny Pacquiao still be considered the P4P KING?

if this does happen and then he fights manny pacqiuao and supposebly beats him then yes....also would like to see him fight cotto and marg too

[AKATheMack]

It would make Floyd the best WW, but P4P would still belong to Manny. If Mosley beats Mayweather he would have a better case for P4P #1 than if Mayweather beats him.

[Clint650]

welterweight is Pac natural weight now. if it isnt then we should expect him to go back down to 140 or 135 but he's not. lets stop saying he's the smaller man, because he isn't.

[AKATheMack]

welterweight is Pac natural weight now. if it isnt then we should expect him to go back down to 140 or 135 but he's not. lets stop saying he's the smaller man, because he isn't.

He won the title at 145, I don't think that makes him a natural WW.

[fcastro1]

welterweight is Pac natural weight now. if it isnt then we should expect him to go back down to 140 or 135 but he's not. lets stop saying he's the smaller man, because he isn't.

no he isn't. his natural weight is 135-140. welterweights rehydrate to 160 pac rehydrates to 149. pac is not a natural welter he is just good enough to fight them.