Boxer with 9(W)-5(L) Record - Good or Bad?

[Tsukiyomi]

I think he would. He's just that good. People act like Floyd cherrypicked people. EVERYONE he fought has asked him to fight them. Hoya, Hatton, everyone. I agree he picked Marquez but that's because Marquez was the p4p #2 and he was setting up a fight with Paquiao, even then. It made sense.

Now we are starting to realize people aren't happy WHOEVER Mayweather chooses.

If it's Shane? Shane's too old
If it was Margarito they'd say "Margarito lost to Shane"

I mean WTF?!! No other fighter gets this.

I think Floyd takes calculated risks. I'm not one to criticize Floyd for fighting Shane, but I think he has been very careful about who he fights. I don't really even hold it against him, it's smart, but not particularly exciting as a fan.

Shane is a legit guy to fight though, can't really criticize him for that.