Who will deserve more props if they win Clottey or Shane?

[-Spinal-]

Based off this it sound like you think Floyd and Manny are equals. If so, you can't say the same about Clottey and Mosley so shouldn't Clottey get more credit for his win seeing as how SSM is superior to him?

They both should get props for beating prime fighters who they are underdog against. But Mosley is better and a much tougher challenge than Clottey. Atm, Mayweather and Pacquiao are equally dominating but that does not change my opinion that Mayweather is better than Pacquiao. Any fighter beating them should get full props.

[jkaisen41]

If Cotto didnt get on his bike then Pac wouldve stopped him in 6. He has mad power at that weight. I mean, Cotto just beat Clottey and Pac killed him. I dont beleive in the trinagle theory **** at all but Im just saying that he can clearly handle himself at WW and its not just all skill. He's physically ****ing these guys up. Even Hatton. It wasnt WW but most thought Hatton was the biggest, strongest, toughest guy at 140 and Pac made him look like a little boy physically. He seemed much more poweful and forceful

I don't know really... he is still heavy handed no question about it... but he lands so many shots on them without ko'ing them. Against Diaz it was a perfect shot that put him away after 9 rounds I believe.

DLH wasn't knocked out...

Hatton walked right into that shot (even if Malignaggi would have thrown a bomb and Hatton would have walked into this he woudld have been st... ahh badly hurt *looooooooooool*)

Cotto was hurt and took the best shots... the second knockdown was a perfect uppercuut but he still continued... of course he was stopped later on and moved a little bit more... his punches are still hurtful but I don't see this super power he had at 126 or 130

Everybody has his opinion... I will watch the Clottey fight... and after that I'm willing to change my mind about that if he really put a hurt on Clottey... who is known for having a good chin and being a big welter (something that Cotto wasn't exactly)

[DonTaseMeBrah]

I don't care where his fights have been, he couldn't make 130 to save his life now and would have trouble making 135. He was 149 vs Cotto, it is not inconceivable that he comes in at 150 or so vs Clottey.

& you know all these things how? how do you know he's 149? they never showed the fight night weights.

[The Great Shark]

Mayweather obviously since he's never been beaten and not many have really come close either. Plus he's the best welterweight right now.