Rank top 5 Welterweights!

[madsweeney]

If we include Margarito

1. Shane Mosley
2. Floyd Mayweather
3. Paul Williams
4. Margarito
5. Manny

Without Margarito

1. Shane Mosley
2. Floyd Mayweather
3. Paul Williams
4. Manny
5. Berto

LOL May #2...what welter weight has he fought? Also, when's the last time PWill fought at WW?


IMO as it stands
1. Mosley
2. Pac (may take #1 after fights)
3. Berto
4. Cotto
5. Clottey

Yes, I left PBF out of the list. How can I rank him top 5 when he hasn't fought ANY WW's in 4+ years?

[Amazinger]

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Shane Mosley
3. Floyd Mayweather
4. Miguel Cotto
5. Joshua Clottey

If you people have these as the top 5 WW.Pac is Cherry picking then huh.

Where is Berto? Is he at least on top 8 I hope.

Mine Is:

1)Shane Mosley
2)Manny Pacquiao
3)Miguel Cotto
4)Antonio Margarito
5) Berto

[fightingfigs]

LOL May #2...what welter weight has he fought? Also, when's the last time PWill fought at WW?


IMO as it stands
1. Mosley
2. Pac (may take #1 after fights)
3. Berto
4. Cotto
5. Clottey

Yes, I left PBF out of the list. How can I rank him top 5 when he hasn't fought ANY WW's in 4+ years?

I feel you, I dont think Mayweather even should be in the top 5 welterweights

[KILLA RIGHT]

If we go based off the better fighters
Floyd
manny
Cotto
Mosley
collazo

If we go based off rankins at ww right now I go
mosley
cotto
manny
Floyd
Collazo

I don't see p will fighting at ww

[Whodini]

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Shane Mosley
3. Floyd Mayweather
4. Miguel Cotto
5. Joshua Clottey

1. Manny Pacquiao
2.Shane Mosley
3. Paul Williams
4. Miguel Cotto
5. Joshua Clottey
.
.
.
100. Floyd Mayweather Jr

[David_TheMan]

LOL May #2...what welter weight has he fought? Also, when's the last time PWill fought at WW?


IMO as it stands
1. Mosley
2. Pac (may take #1 after fights)
3. Berto
4. Cotto
5. Clottey

Yes, I left PBF out of the list. How can I rank him top 5 when he hasn't fought ANY WW's in 4+ years?

How are you going to critique my list but then put Manny at #2 when he has yet to fight a true WW without draining them? Get the **** out of here. Fighting Cotto doesn't make you the number 2 WW in the division. As for Floyd and P-Will both are WW champs and are back in the division, so they will be ranked highly in my eyes.

[street bully]

Cmon how does Mosley get higher than Cotto if he lost to him.

Manny Pacquiao
Paul Williams
Miguel Cotto
Shane Mosley
Floyd Mayweather

What? Dude, give it a break Mosley is the top WW, and Cotto has been KOed twice since then.

[madsweeney]

If you people have these as the top 5 WW.Pac is Cherry picking then huh.

Where is Berto? Is he at least on top 8 I hope.

Mine Is:

1)Shane Mosley
2)Manny Pacquiao
3)Miguel Cotto
4)Antonio Margarito
5) Berto

Who's your # 6? I'm sorry but Marg shouldn't be considered at this point. Hasn't fought in a year and still yet to be licensed.

[madsweeney]

How are you going to critique my list but then put Manny at #2 when he has yet to fight a true WW without draining them? Get the **** out of here. Fighting Cotto doesn't make you the number 2 WW in the division. As for Floyd and P-Will both are WW champs and are back in the division, so they will be ranked highly in my eyes.

Cotto was #2. I'll take his word on weather or not he was drained (he said he felt great.) If you beat a ranked fighter, its very easy to argue that you took their rank.

You included fighters that haven't fought ANYONE in that weight class in YEARS. How ironic that you say beating the #2 guy doesn't make you #2, but beating a ****ing LIGHTWEIGHT makes you #2!! lol

[Amazinger]

Who's your # 6? I'm sorry but Marg shouldn't be considered at this point. Hasn't fought in a year and still yet to be licensed.

The thread only asked us for 5!!!! Helloooooooooo

But that is my top 5...