Pac is top five ATG - Emmanuel Steward

[American Dream]

the torrecampo punch was head shot.

it was a body shot..and he had to be basically carried out of the ring...

[War Dinamita]

A reputable trainer who has seen other greats fight up close says otherwise.

Everyone is entitled to their opinion. Just because an "expert" says Manny is top 5 doesn't mean he's a top 5.

If Manny is top 5... what if Mayweather beats him this year or next year? Does that make Mayweather the greatest of all time?

[rommel357]

Everyone is entitled to their opinion. Just because an "expert" says Manny is top 5 doesn't mean he's a top 5.

But experts has more say and knowledge about this. Kinda like the Hall of Fame in sports, i'm sure many fans don't agree with some of the Hall of Fame inductions or even considerations. But at the end, the experts are the ones that makes the decision and has more credibility.

[pistol whip]

i would match stewards fight knowledge with TheGreatA/TheMachine, and im dead serious. not as a trainer, but pure fight knowledge, the man is an encyclopedia.

Knowledge triva vs understanding every fundamental aspect of the sport and what is required to be a Champion.

Hmmmm I don't think this is even a contest and just because you can name every opponent Joe Louis ever had doesn't qualify you as anything other than a know it all.

[War Dinamita]

But experts has more say and knowledge about this. Kinda like the Hall of Fame in sports, i'm sure many fans don't agree with some of the Hall of Fame inductions or even considerations. But at the end, the experts are the ones that makes the decision and has more credibility.

Saying Manny is top 5 right now, greatest of all time, and Ali of this generation is disrespectful to a lot of fighters.

I don't have a problem if people want to talk about Manny in the top 5, if he beats Mayweather and Mosley. I'll always give people credit when credit is due.

[Ivansmamma]

Emmanuel Steward is top five all time ****** based on this comment.

[SuperTrooper]

Pac is a great fighter, he's in my top 20 ATG but that's just my opinion. Top 5 is stretching it but what do I know, I'm not a boxing guru like Steward. He has seen the light and has become a *******. lol

[TheStoneRoses]

HAHAHHAHHAHA......This is getting ridiculous, they should Just accounce Pacuiao as the KING of the world......pacquiao is not better than Harry Greb, Sugar Ray, Ali, Duran, Louis, Leonard, Armstrong, Holmes, Monzon, Pernell, Cesar Chavez, Hagler etc etc etc

[rommel357]

Saying Manny is top 5 right now, greatest of all time, and Ali of this generation is disrespectful to a lot of fighters.

I don't have a problem if people want to talk about Manny in the top 5, if he beats Mayweather and Mosley. I'll always give people credit when credit is due.

Anybody or anyone could say the same thing with other fighters that are currently on the ATG list. I believe that the one thing that sticks out about Manny is the record for most titles in different weight class.

[rommel357]

Knowledge triva vs understanding every fundamental aspect of the sport and what is required to be a Champion.

Hmmmm I don't think this is even a contest and just because you can name every opponent Joe Louis ever had doesn't qualify you as anything other than a know it all.

It's called Google.