Who's better: Cintron or Clottey? And who would win in a fight?

[mangler jr]

Cintron was supposed to fight Clottey and ducked him.

Clottey is the much better and tougher fighter.

[daggum]

this dumb dumb tries to say marquez was at his best moving up 2 weight divisions then the very next sentence he says oscar was a zombie when he moves down 3 pounds from his last fight. weight does not effect marquez only oscar! weight does not effect mayweather opponents only pac opponents!

[jrosales13]

this dumb dumb tries to say marquez was at his best moving up 2 weight divisions then the very next sentence he says oscar was a zombie when he moves down 3 pounds from his last fight. weight does not effect marquez only oscar! weight does not effect mayweather opponents only pac opponents!

LOL apparently that is how it works around here...

[jkaisen41]

Two questions here, and the answers shouldn't be simple as "Clottey is better, and he'd beat Cintron" or vice versa.

I think it could be that one is the better of the two, but styles wise a fight between the two could produce a different winner.

IMO Clottey is the better of the two overall with his defense, chin, and strength. But I think I would favor Cintron in a fight. Kermit has the power to back him off and better boxing skills that could win him a decision.

What do you say?

Pretty hard to pick honestly... both seem to have mental weaknesses... both have lost to Margarito... Clottey fought Cotto and lost, Cintron fought Martinez and got a draw (which should have been an L)...

Style wise I would pick Cintron but that is based on their style in general... if the fight continues I could see Cintron breaking down... I don't see anyone here gettin ko'd... Clottey doesn't punch hard enough and enough and has himself a solid beard... close decision win for either one

[M.I.C.]

this dumb dumb tries to say marquez was at his best moving up 2 weight divisions then the very next sentence he says oscar was a zombie when he moves down 3 pounds from his last fight. weight does not effect marquez only oscar! weight does not effect mayweather opponents only pac opponents!

When and where did I say that, assuming by dumb dumb you mean me? I'm pretty sure I never said Marquez was at his best at 147, but I did say that that version of Marquez would give Pac a tough fight. Yes indeed.

[M.I.C.]

Well that works both ways cuz Floyd never fought anyone like Pac before in his life... If I am wrong who?

But, OK is cherry picking and Pac has zero... If Floyd fights Pac and wins you can not give Floyd any credit for that win... since he fought some who had zero chance of winning...

I wouldn't consider Pac his greatest victory by any means, its an easy fight.

[jrosales13]

When and where did I say that, assuming by dumb dumb you mean me? I'm pretty sure I never said Marquez was at his best at 147, but I did say that that version of Marquez would give Pac a tough fight. Yes indeed.

How do you think that version of JMM will do against Mosley? Cotto? Antwone Smith? Mike Jones? Margarito? Clottey? Cintron?

[jrosales13]

I wouldn't consider Pac his greatest victory by any means, its an easy fight.

Who would you consider Floyd greatest victory?

[mathed]

Clottey is better than Cintron and beats him in a fight. Clottey was coasting in the Margarito fight till he hurt his hand, could have beaten or drawn with Cotto too. Cintron gets stalked down by Clottey and beaten up against the ropes to lose a decision. Clottey can close the distance rather quickly if needed unlike Angulo who slowly stalks.

[tanibanana]

who is better, Clottey with slight edge...
head-to-head, Clottey by easy win..