Comments Thread For: The Top 25 Middleweights of All-Time – The Top Ten

[jrosales13]

Already have on the research. Patience...

lol... I like reading this kind of stuff... I learn something new everytime, so is hard to have patience lol... out of all these weight-classes that you have done which list did you have the most difficult time making?

[crold1]

lol... I like reading this kind of stuff... I learn something new everytime, so is hard to have patience lol... out of all these weight-classes that you have done which list did you have the most difficult time making?

I thought Welter until I did this one.

[jrosales13]

He is so under appreciated...One of the most skilled fighters Ive ever seen.

Most of his losses came PAST his prime........and he beat and fought everybody........

Johnson
Tarver
Trinidad
Winky
Eastman
Joppy
Echols
Allen
Oscar
Taylor (Close loss)
Taylor 2 (Close loss)
Calzaghe (Close loss)

But, Calzaghe, Tarver, and Winky was not at MW... Is a MW ranking. I do go back and forth on who rates higher between Hopkins and Lamotta. today is Lamotta, tomorrow might be hopkins, I can make a case for either one to be higher... I do think Hopkins is easily top 10 though...

But, my top 5 is...

1. SRR
2. Greb
3. Monzon
4. Hagler
5. Ketchell

[jrosales13]

I thought Welter until I did this one.

Is the MW division the most talented division throughout history?

[crold1]

Is the MW division the most talented division throughout history?

I dunno...everything from Feather to Middle is wildly deep and good. I probably favor Welter for talent but it's a rough run.

[jrosales13]

I dunno...everything from Feather to Middle is wildly deep and good. I probably favor Welter for talent but it's a rough run.

What is next after HW? Are you going to do like a top 25 P4P? I would love to see that... Everybody on here would complain....

[Shadows]

What is next after HW? Are you going to do like a top 25 P4P? I would love to see that... Everybody on here would complain....

I second your last statement. I really enjoy reading Cliff's work, even when I don't agree with what he has to say, or who he picks in a fight. However, I can imagine that list inspiring a 10+ page thread of flaming him.

[crold1]

What is next after HW? Are you going to do like a top 25 P4P? I would love to see that... Everybody on here would complain....

Top 100.

And in violation of regular P4P list rules, I'll include Heavyweights.

[jrosales13]

I second your last statement. I really enjoy reading Cliff's work, even when I don't agree with what he has to say, or who he picks in a fight. However, I can imagine that list inspiring a 10+ page thread of flaming him.

I respect Cliff he does his homework. And, he also gives a reason why he ranks the fighters were they are... so I can't really complain. I can just give my opinion on the matter. But, imagine he does a P4P list? Like you said 10+ page thread of people flaming him.

[crold1]

I respect Cliff he does his homework. And, he also gives a reason why ranks the fighters were they are... But, imagine he does a P4P? like you said 10+ page thread of flaming.

Top 100 will be ten parts all written in the long form of these divisional top tens.