Who Has The Better Resume at 147 Pacquiao or Floyd?

[Sumakwel]

Pacquiao has a better resume than Floyd.

I'll take a Cotto win over Baldomir and Judah.. The real reason why I pick Pacquiao is because he was fighting at 130 pounds last year and he just fought Cotto a year after that.

Mayweather has been in the 147 Pound Division for 5 years and the only fighter he fought is Baldomir considering 147 was pretty stacked up..

[VERDUGO]

Cotto and DelaHoya>>>>>>Judah and Baldomir

[jrosales13]

Cotto>Anybody in Floyd resume.

However overall body of work you have to give it to Floyd he is 5-0 with 2 KO's. Has wins over Judah who was top 5 at the time and Floyd won a lineal belt.

So overall body>2 fights at WW. Even if one of the wins is Cotto and Floyd never fought somebody who was as good Cotto at WW. It won't matter cuz Floyd overall body of work takes this.

[MakeDamnSure]

I picked Pacquiao because Floyd is celebrating his 5 years anniversary in the WW Division and he can't even fight a F U C K I N G Welterweight.

Pacquiao was at 130 lb last year and he fought Cotto way before Floyd did.. Pacquiao is willing to fight Cotto, Margarito and Mosley something Floyd will never have the balls to call out their name.

[project xxx1]

manny has had one fight at ww and that was against weight drained oscar,he fought cotto at catch weight of 145,so that doesnt count,ill take floyds resuma at ww over mannys

[VanillaBuron]

lllllllllllllllllllllllll

[Syf]

well Floyd has Hatton, Judah, Baldomir, and Mitchel... JMM sort of, but not really

Pac,- Dlh and Cotto


JMM was a less than stellar win for Floyd, DLH was a less than stellar win for Pac. so say those cancel each other


you're left with... Judah, Hatton, Baldomir, and Mitchell for Mayweather

and Cotto for Pac.


I vote Mayweather. Judah and Hatton are shells of what they used to be when they fought Mayweather. Baldomir had a rock for a head, and Mitchel was touted by Emanuelle Steward as being trouble for Floyd.

[project xxx1]

Cotto>Anybody in Floyd resume.

However overall body of work you have to give it to Floyd he is 5-0 with 2 KO's. Has wins over Judah who was top 5 at the time and Floyd won a lineal belt.

So overall body>2 fights at WW. Even if one of the wins is Cotto and Floyd never fought somebody who was as good Cotto at WW. It won't matter cuz Floyd overall body of work takes this.

i would argue with that and say ill take floyd wins over oscar at 154 than manny over cotto,simply because margo ***ed cotto career up

[123tyson123]

I made a quick vote for pacquiao.
For me the way he dominated an elite welterweight champion in Cotto is more impressive than any of Mayweathers victorys. And if we are to count Mayweathers victory over Hatton i think its only fair we count Pacquiaos.
Having said that Mayweather has had more fights at the weight against top oposition in Mitchell, Baldomir, Judah and Hatton.
Better resume at the moment, i take my vote back and say Mayweather. I have a good feeling Pacquiao will have the better resume at 147 when they both retire.

[MakeDamnSure]

i would argue with that and say ill take floyd wins over oscar at 154 than manny over cotto,simply because margo ***ed cotto career up

10 people already beat Baldomir and Kosta ruined Judah's career.. The ATG Baldomir according to *****S just beat Judah before that.

I'd take Pac's resume simply because he was fighting at 130 last year Floyd been in that division for 5 years and the best fighter he fought was Baldomir