Comments Thread For: Closing 2009 - BoxingScene’s Pound for Pound Top Ten

[vitali1999]

What a ****ty p4p list, i can agree with the first two, after that it gets a little off.

[dorruel2.0]

Marquez and Vasquez were both off well over a year and, considering their comeback fights (where they both looked depleted), will have been away from top comp for two by the time they see each other again. Those dudes need to beat someone other than each other to get back on as I don't see their fourth fight proving much in terms of the sports elite.

I meant JMM

What a ****ty p4p list, i can agree with the first two, after that it gets a little off.

I agree

[KJB]

I meant JMM

Ill agree they may have dropped JMM a little too far, but he has a point regarding what the future will likely hold. I dont think thats an excuse to drop him that far, otherwise Mosley wouldnt be high on the list either.
The odds that JMM best days are behind him are great, though. Its not very likely he surprises us again, sad to say.

[Lacrimosa]

I don't rate Heavyweights P4P, but understand those who do...

...however...

If the Klits and anyone on this list, or the next ten, were magically the same size, magically retaining all other relative advantages/disadvantages, the Klits would get their ass kicked.

There have been a handful of Heavyweights, ever, who stack up athletically or skill wise with the best smaller men. The Klits ain't among them.

Always found it quite ignorant opinion... Nothing personal... But try to imagine if you try to make Wlad smaller... He has good footwork, nice left hook, ATG jab, explosive right hand, very athletic, weak chin and etc... As you are "making him smaller" you should add some speed... And, can you guess, whom are you getting?

Thomas Hearns, but white...

Yeah... Tommy was a tomato can who got his ass kicked every time he stepped into the ring...

A good big fighter will always look sillier than the good small fighter, despite the fact that the good big man always beats the good small man. If you try to compare fighters of the different weight classes you should think about the speed changes, which will obviously "occur"... And if you do that, any of the Klits is not going to get their ass kicked for the reasons, which surprisingly aren`t obvious for everybody... Damn, both Marciano and Foreman weren`t lightning-fast... Does it mean they would have their ass kicked if "transormed" into smaller men?

If Wlad made a 53(47)-3-0 record by accident, how can one call... say, Joe Calzaghe`s career? Misunderstanding?

[talip bin osman]

i just feel some kinda letdown...

izzy is gone on this list...

i think tim bradley should be higher than dawson...

dawson is quite high...

[lakers24]

wat no klitoris?

[oc9979]

Paul Williams at 4. Paul has been busting his ass, he does deserve that spot. Bradley should be higher then Chad Dawson, lets be real.

There is a double standard because Cotto had a bad fight against Clottey and he got dropped down while Williams had a bad fight against Martinez and he gets moved up.

[Zarco]

wtf? williams at #4? he just edged off a win that many thought martinez should have won. yea it was close but martinez still won.

[DiLLiNGER]

No klitschko brothers??? Common man i know for the fact if they were american they would make the top 5 ...by the way who are hazumi hesegawa and ivan calderon??

[DiLLiNGER]

And shane mosley on # 3??? lmao