Comments Thread For: Closing 2009 - BoxingScene’s Pound for Pound Top Ten

[tocayito1]

bhop ssm and fmj have no business being on this list....

bhop fights blown up middleweights and when he loses he doesnt go down a spot ever.

shane wasnt even on the list but with 1 win he came in at 5 them makes the leap to 3? ******ed

fmj-fighting a jr lightweight at welterweight shouldnt even count on his record


paul williams is high and so is bradley...i think adamek could be on there and jmm being dropped so low is dumb


im not being biased bhop and shane are 2 of my favorites ever but im gona call it like i see it

pwill is overrated but hes a warrior and i have way more respect for him

same for bradley

[Shadows]

Any P4P list that has Calderon ranked over Adamek, Martinez, or Roman Gonzales for that matter has no credibility.

P4P lists are subjective and are based upon opinion. There are no right or wrong answers.

One could easily say that anyone who has Adamek, Martinez, or Gonzalez ahead of Calderon has no credibility.

[v.cassiusali@ya]

i don't argue chicken floyd's being in the #2 position if he does knockout marquez who was relatively smaller than him. chicken floyd even cheated his weight just to ensure his weight and height advantage over marquez but he failed to ko or even knockdown the aging mexican.

that spot should belong to juanma lopez.