Either Calzaghe is ATG, or Bhop should be dropped from Top 10

[larry x]

joe-21 title defenses..won every belt at 168..moved up to 175 and won the ring belt.......why the hate???

b-hop-20 title defenses won all the belts at 160-moved up and won the ring belt at 175

sounds like 2 mirror image careers if you ask me

the only differance you ask???ones american..and one isnt

[Doctor_Tenma]

What does he have to do to earn a spot on the ATG list?

Should he have gotten KO'd by a tibetan midget early in his career like Pacquiao did?

Does he need to make a rap album about all the boxers he destroyed?

Honestly please tell me what he has to do to get in the Hall of Fame!!!

Listen, Calzaghe's best win is Kessler who hasn't really beaten anyone. Doesn't help that Kessler who was favored to win the tournament got badly outclassed by an inexperienced figher, Ward.

[jrosales13]

21 succesfull title defenses at SMW, won all 5 major belts and unified the division twice. Not even your hero Floyd comes close to that. Then he moves up and takes on the recognized best LHW and beats him.


Calzaghe should be in everybbodys 100 ATG fighters period!!!!!

He is not in my top 100. There are too many great fighters in the history of the sport to consider Joe top 100. He is a sure HOF'er without a doubt. But, not top 100.

[Doctor_Tenma]

It seems very obvious to me.

People who hate white boxers will never give Calzaghe credit, no matter what, and will always seek to prove he really wasn't any good. It's because they deeply believe that all white boxers are inferior.

Hate white boxers? That's clearly a racist. Calzaghe is a really good fighter, ATG no.

[jrosales13]

It seems very obvious to me.

People who hate white boxers will never give Calzaghe credit, no matter what, and will always seek to prove he really wasn't any good. It's because they deeply believe that all white boxers are inferior.

Where have you ever seen in any of my post where I have hated white fighters. Look at the search at all my previous post. And, fine one. I will give you all my points if you do.

[Doctor_Tenma]

What does he have to do to earn a spot on the ATG list?

Should he have gotten KO'd by a tibetan midget early in his career like Pacquiao did?

Does he need to make a rap album about all the boxers he destroyed?

Honestly please tell me what he has to do to get in the Hall of Fame!!!

For one,

Ward, Froch, Dirrell, AA, Bute are out there. There is alot he can do but if he doesn't have the drive anymore, I don't blame him.

[The Hammer]

Where have you ever seen in any of my post where I have hated white fighters. Look at the search at all my previous post. And, fine one. I will give you all my points if you do.

This one, your second post. You refuse to recognize Calzaghe because he's white.

"I don't have Joe in the top 100 I don't care what nobody says."

[Sick/]

Hate white boxers? That's clearly a racist. Calzaghe is a really good fighter, ATG no.

List your top 100 ATG's then please

[jrosales13]

What does he have to do to earn a spot on the ATG list?

Honestly please tell me what he has to do to get in the Hall of Fame!!!

He is a sure fire HOF'er. I don't think nobody is saying different. I am saying he does not belong in the top 100. Domi is saying he is not ATG. But, he is a hall of famer.

[Doctor_Tenma]

Where have you ever seen in any of my post where I have hated white fighters. Look at the search at all my previous post. And, fine one. I will give you all my points if you do.

He constantly plays the race card. Has nothing to with Calzaghe being white.