Either Calzaghe is ATG, or Bhop should be dropped from Top 10

[The Hammer]

I don't have Joe in the top 100 I don't care what nobody says.

And, why make such a big deal for P4P list. I can say Calderon is my #1 P4P. You can not say is wrong cuz it is all an opinion.

You are clearly racist.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Paul Williams should be above Mosley-Hopkins-and Mayweather on any p4p list

Lol! say wut?

[Doctor_Tenma]

You are clearly racist.

Why does everything have to do with race? Serious question.

[DiegoFuego]

No way is Calzaghe an ATG. You beat two middle-aged former greats and think you're big and bad? His best win after Hopkins was Kessler, and Ward just destroyed Kessler in a way Calzaghe couldn't. Calzaghe is nothing in my eyes. Nothing.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

I give Joe respect but he isn't an ATG, not even close.

21 succesfull title defenses at SMW, won all 5 major belts and unified the division twice. Not even your hero Floyd comes close to that. Then he moves up and takes on the recognized best LHW and beats him.


Calzaghe should be in everybbodys 100 ATG fighters period!!!!!

[Doctor_Tenma]

21 succesfull title defenses at SMW, won all 5 major belts and unified the division twice. Not even your hero Floyd comes close to that. Then he moves up and takes on the recognized best LHW and beats him.


Calzaghe should be in everybbodys 100 ATG fighters period!!!!!

If Calzaghe is an ATG, guess it isn't too hard to be one. Throw DLH and Mosley in there too, In my opinion both have done more.

[jrosales13]

You are clearly racist.

lol how? I have Greb in the top 3 what race is he? I have Pep and B. Leonard in the top 10? What race are they? I have Jake Lamotta in the top 25 and in the top 5 MW of all time what race is he? I have Stanley Ketchell in the top 5 MW of all time also what race is he? I say P4P Jimmy Wilde is hardest puncher of all time and he is in my top 20 what race is he? I Bob Fitzsimmons in my top 15 what race is he? I have gone on record on here and say Bute is the #1 SMW over Ward. What race is he?

I consider Joe as sure fire HOF'er how is that racist. I never said he is borderline or anything like that. I said sure HOF'er. How is that racist? Cuz I don't have him in the top 100?

I consider Joe an ATG SMW. So how am I racist? I just don't think he is top 100? I don't think Shane is top 100 what race is he? I might not even have Oscar in my top 100 what race is he? GTFOH with the racist ****... You the racist you do not give no black or hispanic fighters credit.

[The Hammer]

Why does everything have to do with race? Serious question.

It seems very obvious to me.

People who hate white boxers will never give Calzaghe credit, no matter what, and will always seek to prove he really wasn't any good. It's because they deeply believe that all white boxers are inferior.

[Joeyzagz]

I give Joe respect but he isn't an ATG, not even close.

What does he have to do to earn a spot on the ATG list?

Should he have gotten KO'd by a tibetan midget early in his career like Pacquiao did?

Does he need to make a rap album about all the boxers he destroyed?

Honestly please tell me what he has to do to get in the Hall of Fame!!!

[jrosales13]

No way is Calzaghe an ATG. You beat two middle-aged former greats and think you're big and bad? His best win after Hopkins was Kessler, and Ward just destroyed Kessler in a way Calzaghe couldn't. Calzaghe is nothing in my eyes. Nothing.

What about at SMW? Is he ATG SMW?