Miguel Cotto is NOT an ATG

[Easy-E]

he does have a arguably better resume than floyd does

brutal self abuse.

[RockStar45]

he does have a arguably better resume than floyd does

He has Mosley, who's a better fighter than anyone Floyd has on his list, but he doesn't have the all-around body of work or the all-time skills Floyd has. That's why he won't be considered anywhere near Mayweather all-time.

[Kball15]

A dominant performance over a prime Diego Corrales is a better win than Cottos Narrow points win over Mosley.

Just my opinion though....

[Tha_Greatest]

He has Mosley, who's a better fighter than anyone Floyd has on his list, but he doesn't have the all-around body of work or the all-time skills Floyd has. That's why he won't be considered anywhere near Mayweather all-time.

thats why i said arguably, mays all around is resume is better

by the way, even though i thought cotto lost barely to clottey, he also has beaten clottey , by the way, just like i thought floyd shouldve lost to castillo, (1st fight only)

[Tha_Greatest]

A dominant performance over a prime Diego Corrales is a better win than Cottos Narrow points win over Mosley.

Just my opinion though....

i wont argue with this cause floyd beat the crap outta corrales and knocked him down 5 times

[razor.thin]

pacquiao is the only active atg boxer today.

[Tha_Greatest]

pacquiao is the only active atg boxer today.

hopkins is as well,

[Earl-Hickey]

He has Mosley, who's a better fighter than anyone Floyd has on his list, but he doesn't have the all-around body of work or the all-time skills Floyd has. That's why he won't be considered anywhere near Mayweather all-time.

Molsey, is well known for having "off nights" where he just doesn't show up, i think we can all say for sure now, thats what happened in the Cotto fight.

[vercingetorix3]

One of the greatest of his era? Without a doubt.

All-time great? Hardly.

[Liar]

He isn’t even a hall of famer