Who has defeated more fighters in their PRIME: Mayweather or Pacquiao?

[carts]

Juddi Dalli being eaten alive again with his BS thread IMO lol..

[jkaisen41]

Mate


You dont have the right to argue about Resumes. You dont even know who Ledwabba and Sasakul are.


in reality Pacquiao ****s on Floyds Resume.... Pac has more fights with better fighters.

These are two fighters and... I seriously doubt that they are great or? If they were I'm pretty much sure I would have heard of them or???

That's your opinion... I disagree respectfully... he has more fights with fighters who have a better resume... but that doesn't mean that they were any better then Floyd opponents... like said... Morales and Barrera pretty much made themselves great... it's not like they beaten legends or something... they had each other... Marquez was a good fighter but pretty much became fame through Pacquiao... it's not like they beat any of higher notice... they had each other... so of course they have a great on their resume... Floyd beat all champions that were there at his reign who wanted some (130/135)... so I have no problem for that...

But I know who Jesus Chavez is... so I think I have the right to answer for him if somebody puts him into the dirt to make his fighter look better or???

[BennyST]

Pacquiao easily.



Manny Pacquiao

MAB
JMM
Sasakul
Ledwabba
Hatton
Cotto
Diaz


Floyd

Corrales
Castillo
Baldo ( WTF??!! LOL )



7-3 Pacquiao!

What the ****? Mate, you seem like one of the more semi-reasonable Pacfans on here but what are you smoking? How do you put Hatton on Pac's when Mayweather fought the undefeated version over a year before?

You also laughing at Balodomir on Mayweather's but put Diaz on Pac's? Come one man, try having a bit of reason here.

Going through them with prime or close to prime fighters the best list would be something like this (and I'm only going to put in the top guys):
Mayweather: Corrales
Castillo
Hernandez
Chavez (not sure if this should be in there as a top guy or not)
Hatton
Corley
Judah (not sure about this one either. He was close I guess)

Pac: Sasakul
Ledwaba
Barrera
Marquez (this is as debatable as Judah I think. Although still very good he was 36 and had slowed from their last fight)
Diaz (if we have Chavez we have Diaz)
Cotto
Hatton (I personally think Hatton was done, but he had just beaten Paulie so I guess he also fits)

Seven each. Both the same.

[BennyST]

These are two fighters and... I seriously doubt that they are great or? If they were I'm pretty much sure I would have heard of them or???


But I know who Jesus Chavez is... so I think I have the right to answer for him if somebody puts him into the dirt to make his fighter look better or???

Ledwaba was **** but Sasakul was a very good fighter man. That's a good win for Pac. He was a top fighter and champion before and after Pac. Ledwaba wasn't very good before Pac and retired straight after. He wasn't much to begin with.

Sasakul was better than Jesus 'El Matador' Chavez though. Chavez is a D. Diaz level guy. Though if they fought years ago Chavez would have whipped him.

Their resumes are very similar in all reality.

[El Jesus]

Ledwaba was **** but Sasakul was a very good fighter man. That's a good win for Pac. He was a top fighter and champion before and after Pac. Ledwaba wasn't very good before Pac and retired straight after. He wasn't much to begin with.

Sasakul was better than Jesus 'El Matador' Chavez though. Chavez is a D. Diaz level guy. Though if they fought years ago Chavez would have whipped him.

Their resumes are very similar in all reality.

Irconically those two would end up having a "who wants to retire first" fight recently. Chavez was done the moment his knee gave in on him during the Julio Diaz fight, i dont even see why he feels the need to continue.

Its funny when you think about someone of David Diaz calbur being on the same team as Tarver, Reid, Mayweather and Vargas as well as Zahir Raheem, all guys that kill him in the skill department.

[El Jesus]

I also realized that mayweather is 17-0 in title fights, considering its through 5 weight classes thats very impressive. Not obviously as impressive at 7 titles, but still, thats incredible.

[miron_lang]

What the ****? Mate, you seem like one of the more semi-reasonable Pacfans on here but what are you smoking? How do you put Hatton on Pac's when Mayweather fought the undefeated version over a year before?

You also laughing at Balodomir on Mayweather's but put Diaz on Pac's? Come one man, try having a bit of reason here.

Going through them with prime or close to prime fighters the best list would be something like this (and I'm only going to put in the top guys):
Mayweather: Corrales
Castillo
Hernandez
Chavez (not sure if this should be in there as a top guy or not)
Hatton
Corley
Judah (not sure about this one either. He was close I guess)

Pac: Sasakul
Ledwaba
Barrera
Marquez (this is as debatable as Judah I think. Although still very good he was 36 and had slowed from their last fight)
Diaz (if we have Chavez we have Diaz)
Cotto
Hatton (I personally think Hatton was done, but he had just beaten Paulie so I guess he also fits)

Seven each. Both the same.

lol its a mistake on my part. i already apologized to the idiot TS


Hernadez? Carlos? Genaro? and you didnt include Larios who went on to win another title above the division he previously won. That was Genaro's last professional fight. while Larios went on to win another title


You included Corley but Not Nedal Hussein and Jorge Solis? All of them title chalengers. Even Farrakob Rakkiatgym is also a 2 time World title chalenger.


Hector Velasquez is also prime.

[J.Dempsey]

I Ippy-dippied and it landed on Pacquiao, sry guys...
On paper I think mayweather has beaten more prime fighters, but for some reason pacquiao seems to suprise me more...
Hmmmmm

[miron_lang]

Ledwaba was **** but Sasakul was a very good

LOL

at that time Ledwabba was the TOP DOG @122 Geoge Foreman was all praise for him.

[El Jesus]

lol its a mistake on my part. i already apologized to the idiot TS


Hernadez? Carlos? Genaro? and you didnt include Larios who went on to win another title above the division he previously won. That was Genaro's last professional fight. while Larios went on to win another title


You included Corley but Not Nedal Hussein and Jorge Solis? All of them title chalengers


Hector Velasquez is also prime.

Oscar Larios was totally finished after he fought vasquez for that third time, people had been calling for him to retire for years and in reality that was a stay busy fight. Jorge Solis and Hussein arent that great at all, Jorge's brother is another story.

If im not mistaken Larios won one of those bull**** international belts i think but that was about it. Genaro was undefeated at 130 before he fought floyd, his only loss came at the hands of a young de la hoya one division up, thats why that fight was so signifigant, not to mention floyd was an underdog and had only been pro about a year and a half.