Who has defeated more fighters in their PRIME: Mayweather or Pacquiao?

[al-Xander]

Dumb, Just because you lost 1 fight you're not prime anymore?

Judah lost to Baldimor before Floyd fought him
Baldomir has 10 losses
Castillo already lost several times before he fought Floyd meaning a past his prime Castillo beat Floyd.

Hatton strugled at 147 against Collazo and Floyd fought him out of his weight..

What's your definition of prime? When a Fighter lost once? Floyd never fought any Prime Fighter

That's what I don't get in this forum. It you lose one fight
as a boxer, your next opponent shouldn't be credited because
he just fought a loser. Is it even possible that this TS and his
moronic ilk don't know that people have the capacity to make
a comeback? Are we really that fragile as human beings like ******
people in this forum lead us to believe? Training and preparation
no longer matters?

If this is what it means to be a hardcore or real boxing fan in this
forum, man, I'd rather be a casual fan. I want none of this crap.

[SCtrojansbaby]

That's what I don't get in this forum. It you lose one fight
as a boxer, your next opponent shouldn't be credited because
he just fought a loser. Is it even possible that this TS and his
moronic ilk don't know that people have the capacity to make
a comeback? Are we really that fragile as human beings like ******
people in this forum lead us to believe? Training and preparation
no longer matters?

If this is what it means to be a hardcore or real boxing fan in this
forum, man, I'd rather be a casual fan. I want none of this crap.

No they shouldn't be credited. Real champions don't fight guys coming off losses

[frankenfrank]

Common Opponents : JMM , DLH , Hatton , and now it is going to be Mosley.
3 of which Floyd fought first and Pacquiao later.
Floyd wears them down and Pacquiao capitalizes on their corpses .

[Cash Cow]

Manny has
Morales 2x Barrera 2x Ledwaba

Floyd has
Hatton and Corralles

Anyone saying Floyd simply doesn't know anything about boxing.

he lost to morales ( a washed up morales) and his 2nd win vs MAB was vs a washed up MAB......ledwaba?

[Cash Cow]

Easily Maywerather. Not only were Diego & Hatton undefeated they were both top ranked P4P at the time Floyd fought them. He also beat other in their prime champions like Angel Manfreddy & Judah. Haters try to pretend Oscar was so old but Oscar was only 4 years older than Floyd also at the time they fought.

i agree....

[Cash Cow]

if floyd beats pac, his biggest win is against past prime wh0 has been KO two times.

[imperfek]

this is an easy one, mayweather by far
yet pacquiao still winning the votes wtf? most of the fighters he fought were months or years older than when mayweather took them on
>*******s

[viperz007]

this is an easy one, mayweather by far
yet pacquiao still winning the votes wtf?
>*******s

u bump this thread to get owned?

what a poor dude

u call ortiz prime?

because he beat berto by KO?

oh i forgot it was a UD

berto who?

[hugh grant]

The out of prime fighters Pac fights, are better than the in prime fighters Floyd ever fights.
Other than that, Pac beats Floyds opponents better in a way Floyd couldnt. Like Floyd wouldnt ever knock Hatton out in 2 rounds or make DLH quit.

[straightleft]

Pac beat these prime fighters

Sasakul - linear champ
Ledwaba
Barrera 2x linear champ, future HOF
Marquez 2x scoring error, linear champ, future HOF
Morales 2x future HOF
Hatton - linear champ
Cotto
Diaz
Clottey
Solis 30-0-2 young lion and undefeated
Lucero 21-0-1 young lion and undefeated
Hussien 19-0-0 young lion and undefeated
Chae 23-0-0 young lion and undefeated

Total 16!