Who has defeated more fighters in their PRIME: Mayweather or Pacquiao?

[SkillspayBills]

Mayweather by a landslide.

[Cash Cow]

wtf is meant by "prime" fighters. are we talkin about prime champions or just prime fighters in general they have faced? because a lot of bums can be **** but still be considered in their prime...

who fought more fighters in or around their primes?

[SkillspayBills]

Of course like any Mayweather-Pac poll it will turn into who likes either fighter more. To be honest though, It's got to be Floyd. Hatton, Corrales,Baldo,Judah,Castillo and pretty much everyone he faced at 130 was in their prime.

[Cash Cow]

Of course like any Mayweather-Pac poll it will turn into who likes either fighter more. To be honest though, It's got to be Floyd. Hatton, Corrales,Baldo,Judah,Castillo and pretty much everyone he faced at 130 was in their prime.

I agree

[DiLLiNGER]

worthy opponents ..floyd all day long.

[Rome-By-Ko]

Neither really fought alot of prime fighters.But the edge would go to Mayweather on this one.

[Rome-By-Ko]

mayweather, he fought top p4p hatton,chico who were also undeafed at the time
-judah,Castillo,Balomir,Angel Manfreddy,corley,hernandez
and he also fought a better non weight drained delahoya

Judah was not prime
Castillo was not prime
Baldy was not prime
Hernandez was not prime
Other then that the other fighters were prime(Not Hoya either)May has fought more prime fighters.

[Baba Konuwa]

hatton was at his prime weight vs pac and not for mayweather. you were right 7-3.

Hatton walks around almost 180, so actually he is bigger than Floyd and Manny. It is well documented that Hatton was having trouble making 140, Freddie Roach admits hand picking opponents. He knew Eric Morales couldn't make 130 anymore in their 3rd fight. He knew Oscar didn't have it anymore and couldn't make 147, He knew Hatton had trouble making 140, and he put's catch weights on nearly everyone Pacquiao fights @ Welterweight. He even suggested making Mosley come down to a catch weight of 143 for a fight with Pacquiao. Manny is a great fighter, but a made up mega star and he definitely hasn't fought more fighters in their prime or better competition than Mayweather.

[S H A R K B O Y]

Again, Mayweather fought more fighters at the top of their game.

[Baba Konuwa]

Do i really need to explain? Mayweather was always getting **** for his resume before he fought Mosley, and since he beat Mosley now suddenly he's beat better opponents than Pacquiao? It was a great win dont get me wrong but to say he has beat better in prime boxers than Pacquiao is absurd. Mayweather got no reconizition before the Mosley fight.. now he beat him he's all of a sudden beat more-in prime boxers? Mosley wasn't prime either. Perhaps your just biased but as of fan of both.. Mayweather hasn't surpassed Pacquiao's record just yet.

Mayweather gets hated on because of the persona he displays to the media. Yes Mayweather has fought better competition. He beat Genarro Hernadez who was undefeated at 130 lbs and is a HOF, when Mayweather only had 17 fights, he beat Manfredy another 130 lb title holder in his prime, Diego Corrales who was knocking everybody out and was undefeated,Jesus Chavez #1 Contender for the jr lightweight title in his prime. he beat Emmanuel Burton, Jose Luis Castillo twice (lightweight champion), He fought Ndou in his prime, Chop Chop Corley in his prime @ 140, Sharmbai Mitchell (Who Emmanuel Stewart predicted to beat Mayweather) Zab Judah in his prime @ 147,Balodmir ( Undisputed Welterweight Champion in his prime), Del La Hoya at his natural weight class of 154 lbs, Hatton when he was the ring magazine champ @ 140 and undefeated. Also lets talk abou t the way he beats them all.... Easily there is no wars or back in forth action, it's a straight up ass whipping every time no matter who it is, he beats them all the same way. Pacquiao's team has strategically planned his major fights when mega stars were over the hill. Freddie Roach blatantly admits his strategy. Also you don't know **** about boxing all you know is what Dan Rafael says and the bull **** they write in the media, so don't comment anymore.