Where Do You Rank Floyd as an ATG?

[123tyson123]

PBF and Pac are highly regarded. Its just that PBF is more highly criticised as well.
If PBF can beat Pac is it is just about the best win he can get thats available to him. But Pac is still a higher ATG whatever happens.

BTW is there an official ATG list that is the most respected? Is it Ring Mag, or HBOs list.?
What is the official current list?

I agree mayweathers more criticized, this is because pacquiaos style is more fan friendly. I dont agree with pacquiao being higher atg whatever happens. What makes you think this?

And no theres no official list, its just a matter of opinion mate. I think most fans will consider Ray Robinson the best fighter to ever live. Others will pick Ali, Duran even Mayweather or Pacquiao. Just a matter of opinion.

[tibbar]

As a Pac fan, I know I'm looking through rose-tinted glasses but Floyd isn't in the top-20 ATGs, IMHO.

Even if he beats Pac, I don't think he'll surpass his legacy in the sport.

With that out of my chest, it's now your turn to asses Floyd's legacy.

Where does he rank in the ATG list? Do explain your ranking likewise.

I rank him TOP ATG in England well you can disagree with and itll be alright.

[talip bin osman]

What IF floyd really dominated him and makes him look amatuer? just for kicks?

so what?

iran barkley decimated tommy hearns in just under 3 rounds in their first fight...

a points win in their second...

mr. hearns is 0-2 against him...

[Killa_Kali]

Poll Results: Where Do You Rank Floyd as an ATG?
Greatest of All Time 2 3.33%
In the top 10 8 13.33%
In the top 20 10 16.67%
In the top 30 10 16.67%
In the top 40 and below 24 40.00%
Bobby Pacquiao has a higher ATG ranking than Floyd 6 10.00%

[Killa_Kali]

Most people consider Duran top 15 if not top 10 so it's not really shameful to not be as high as him.

i rank duran way higher than floyd.