Who would Floyd have to beat to catch Manny on the all time list?

[Doctor_Tenma]

c'mon... just cause margo is scandalized and pac ruined cotto doesn't mean floyd can duck them.

you can't get credit for fights unless you actually fight them.

Cotto isn't the same anymore, I've said this for a while now. Margarito has to work his way up again and who knows if Mayweather will still be in the game by the time Margarito does that. Who knows if Margarito will even be fighting at WW.

[sycomantz]

c'mon... just cause margo is scandalized and pac ruined cotto doesn't mean floyd can duck them.

you can't get credit for fights unless you actually fight them.

shut up man, cottos washed up

and ducked floyd when floyd called him out


next

[Roger Mellie]

You would have to put Paul Williams into the equation.

[mushahadeen]

To catch Manny on the all time list Floyd would have to start fighting fighters in his division.

[Xcusemymood]

At 32 does he have the time or the quality of opponents to catch up and overhaul Manny's achievements? are the fights even out there for him?

Discuss.

Id say if he beats Pac, then Mosley, and moves up to middleweight in a couple years and grabs a belt(Sturm? Clearly belt counting doesnt matter who you are fighting if were counting Diaz and Cotto @145 for Pac). He'll be at least on par if not higher.

[Bigchill79]

Surpasses Pac's CV already

[Xcusemymood]

true PACxing fans right here...

Funny thing is he already has a belt at 154. But thats not counted as moving up cause its Floyd and he only fights smaller fighters.

[Xcusemymood]

he's gotta beat atleast mosley, cotto, and margo and a few 140 lbs who can prove that they belong at 147

I take it you dont think Hatton counts at 147 even though he won a belt and (questionably) beat Collazo? Ill agree that maybe 140 was his best weight but I have a hard time saying he had no business there because regardless he was pretty competitive.

[Kevin Jesus]

He has already beaten Judah, DLH, Hatton, Baldomir, Castillo x2, Corrales and amassed arguably the greatest 130 run of titles defences of all time. He's right up there with Pac - there should be no arguments about this.

The most unbiased post any poster can make in a Pacquiao-Mayweather thread. You just gave credit to both of them instead of siding with one and make the other one look like they wre given the spot they are at right now. Green k.

[Kevin Jesus]

he'll get my props if he beats pac, cleans up the current WW division, and grabs a belt at 154 before retiring.

He's a former 154 WBC champion. That was 2 years ago, though i understand you recently started watching boxing



















Jk


But he is a former 154 WBC champ though Kila.