Who would Floyd have to beat to catch Manny on the all time list?

[hugh grant]

Rubbish mate,as soon as JMM got ****y floyd rocked him to the floor..floyd needed the fight to go to the distance for his own good,remember he was out of the ring for about 2 years,and stop with the weight ****,ricky looked healthy against floyd when he fought manny he looked like a tooth pick the same goes for oscar de la hoya.

Floyd beat the hatton who beat kostya tszyu,after the loss he wasn't the same fighter period!!

Mine wasnt rubbish, yours is! No. Floyd beat the Hatton Collazo nearly beat more like it. So Floyd did slightly better than Collazo. But Collazo softened hatton up for floyd.

[Roger Mellie]

As pointed out elsewhere in this thread, PBF doesn't automatically envelop all of Manny's accolades. He can prove himself as the better fighter man to man by winning. But not the greater fighter overall career wise.

That is the point. The thread was made to rip the piss out of the *****s,and in that regard it worked a treat. One thing it is important to remember though,is that if Floyd does manage to beat Pac,then he will deserve massive credit for doing it,seeing how well Manny has done coming up through the weights. It wouldnt be fair to play the smaller man card on Floyd after seeing Pacs strength and dominant performances of late.

The winner of this fight will garner the utmost respect and so could the loser if it turns out to be a classic,remember this is the two greatest fighters of the era squaring off.

[miron_lang]

He has already beaten Judah, DLH, Hatton, Baldomir, Castillo x2, Corrales and amassed arguably the greatest 130 run of titles defences of all time. He's right up there with Pac - there should be no arguments about this.

No way! That is **** compared to Pac's resume. You can pick this apart but i can also do that to your tiny list.

The Legends

Marco Antonio Barrera - One of the best pound for pound fighters in the world and Linear Featherweight champion. - TKO11, UD12

Erik Morales - 3 Division champion. One of the best pound for pound fighters. TKO10, KO3

Juan Manuel Marquez - Former Featherweight, S. Feather and Lightweight Champion - SD12

Oscar DelaHoya - 6 Division World Champion. TKO8




The Champions

Miguel Cotto - Considered the #2 Welterweight behind Mosley whom he beat. 3 Time, 2 Division Champion. TKO12

Ricky Hatton - Linear Champion at 140. Undefeated at 140. KO2

Oscar Larios - 2 Weight Division champion. A champion before and after Pac - UD

Chatchai Sasakul - A linear Flyweight champion and has legendary status in Thailand. TKO8

Lehlohonolo Ledwabba - The best 122lbs fighter at the time. p4p fighter Top 15. TKO6

David Diaz - Kayoed Sta. Cruz who beat Cassamayor but lost in the cards. TKO 9

Jorge Elicier Julio - 2 Time World Champion never been stopped before. KO2





The Contenders


Jorge Solis - Undefeated chalenger (33-0). Fought for World title TKO8

Nedal Hussein - Title chalenger. Very tough and dirty fighter. TKO10

Hector Velasquez - A class A journeyman TKO6

Emmanuel Lucero - Undefeated chalenger TKO3

Fahprakorb Rakkiatgym - 2 time Championship chalenger KO1

[miron_lang]

At 32 does he have the time or the quality of opponents to catch up and overhaul Manny's achievements? are the fights even out there for him?

Discuss.

Beating Pacquiao, Mosley-berto Winner, Paul Williams and Kelly Pavlik


It's not impossible.

[talip bin osman]

Beating Pacquiao, Mosley-berto Winner, Paul Williams and Kelly Pavlik


It's not impossible.

yeah its not...

not at all impossible...

but im really skeptical about it happening...

[lyricalether]

cotto and paul williams and or mosley

[-Spinal-]

Lol this thread was hilarious.


"It was just a wind up thread" Yeah sure after getting pwned.

[SonOfCuba]

he would have to beat Manny Pacquiao