Noticing people saying Wiliiams-Martinez was NOT a robbery

[hammerhiem]

Had the douche Judge scored it 115-114 for Williams no one would have grumbled and Williams would have a MD win.

So not a robbery just an incompetant judge

[Iceta]

That one scorecard put a dark shadow on this great fight. You can't deny that.

[Idgas]

Not a robbery? If Martinez scored a 10-6 round, he would still loose the fight? How is that not a robbery?

Do you even know what a robbery is? A robbery is when you have already lost before you even get in the ring.

my definition of a robbery is when a fighter loses when he clearly won. last night's fight was not a very clear fight. i had martinez winning but i could see how other people could have scored it for williams. you're focused on that one judge. if they had a fair judge, this fight wouldn't be so controversial. this is just a case of one judge ruining the whole score.

[Zarco]

my definition of a robbery is when a fighter loses when he clearly won. last night's fight was not a very clear fight. i had martinez winning but i could see how other people could have scored it for williams. you're focused on that one judge. if they had a fair judge, this fight wouldn't be so controversial. this is just a case of one judge ruining the whole score.

if martinez scored 5 knocked downs, he would have still lost. if thats not a robbery to you then i dont know what is. that judge went into the fight knowing who he was going to pick.

[JMM_135_#1]

if martinez scored 5 knocked downs, he would have still lost. if thats not a robbery to you then i dont know what is. that judge went into the fight knowing who he was going to pick.

no he wouldnt have , i noticed you have ignored my post explaining this, do the math

the only way it would work how your saying is if paul had gone down 5 times in one round..... after which im pretty sure the fight would have been stopped

[Idgas]

if martinez scored 5 knocked downs, he would have still lost. if thats not a robbery to you then i dont know what is. that judge went into the fight knowing who he was going to pick.

yea i got that. you said that already. problem here is that you are so sure that martinez won while others have it a close fight that could have gone either way. no surprise you're screaming robbery.

[Zarco]

yea i got that. you said that already. problem here is that you are so sure that martinez won while others have it a close fight that could have gone either way. no surprise you're screaming robbery.

the point here is not to talk about how i have it scored or how every other fan has it scored. the point is to talk about a judge who was hired to rob no matter what. the other judges would have leveled it out but the point is that there was a man that martinez was against sitting on the judges seat.

no he wouldnt have , i noticed you have ignored my post explaining this, do the math

the only way it would work how your saying is if paul had gone down 5 times in one round..... after which im pretty sure the fight would have been stopped

how did that benoist judge score the first round? do you know?

[JMM_135_#1]

the point here is not to talk about how i have it scored or how every other fan has it scored. the point is to talk about a judge who was hired to rob no matter what. the other judges would have leveled it out but the point is that there was a man that martinez was against sitting on the judges seat.

how did that benoist judge score the first round? do you know?

no i have a sneaking suspiscion it was for williams

[Idgas]

the point here is not to talk about how i have it scored or how every other fan has it scored. the point is to talk about a judge who was hired to rob no matter what. the other judges would have leveled it out but the point is that there was a man that martinez was against sitting on the judges seat.

benoist is a bull**** judge, no one's arguing that.

[Zarco]

no i have a sneaking suspiscion it was for williams

Ok just got it off another thread.

so here is benoist's official score card:

Martinez: 10 10 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 = 110
Williams: 10 9 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 = 119

your right i was exaggerating about the 4 KD's.

but say he scored 2 more knockdowns after the first 2 rounds?

Martinez: 10 10 9 9 9 10 10 9 9 9 9 9 = 112
Williams: 10 9 10 10 10 9 9 10 10 10 10 10 = 115

thats still a major robbery not to give it to martinez. that judge being there made the fight a robbery.