MAYWEATHER should not be consider a 6 time world champion!

[-EX-]

The thing is that we don't know right. Cuz they never fought. Spadafora was calling Floyd out

Beating someone in the amateurs aint the same as the pros...ask Mark Breland

I hope you aren't siding with the thread starter...

[baracuda]

yeah didnt kelson pinto and abdullaev beat cotto in the amateurs and get stopped in the pros?

lol...i never said cotto have more talent in his pinkie than the guys who at one point beat him.....did' i ?.......im not even gonna remind you about pre pac vs cotto...

[deliveryman]

Teens my ass.

This is tournament for OLYMPIC GAMES.

Teens your ass?

At the time Zab Judah and David Diaz were both nineTEEN years old.

[jrosales13]

judah lost to baldo as well do you think he was more talented or judah wasnt mentally all there for that fight? see my last post for examples of amateur and pro fights and how they differ

Mentally is the biggest thing in boxing. I am sorry if you don't have the mentality then you are not a good boxer. I don't care how fast you are, how hard you hit, and how good move. if you not there mentally then you are not going to be good. Oba Carr had skills but he didn't have the mental part of the game. So to answer your question obviously Baldomir won. Baldomir was the better fighter. Judah should of gotten a rematch and proved other wise.

[baracuda]

Beating someone in the amateurs aint the same as the pros...ask Mark Breland

I hope you aren't siding with the thread starter...

ts has a good point tho.......how could you still have a belt after losing a fight at a weight you won the belt from?....

[jrosales13]

Beating someone in the amateurs aint the same as the pros...ask Mark Breland

I hope you aren't siding with the thread starter...

You put Spadafora as an example which was a bad example. The point of this argument was that Judah should of not had a title when he fought Floyd. Cuz he lost to Baldomir. NY made cameback with saying well Diaz was the weakest. Zab has more skills than David. But, you can't compare cuz Diaz was a legit title holder who was undefeated as a LW. While Zab was coming of a lose. What side are you taking bro?

[ny123]

But, Cotto beat them as a pro. Did Zab beat Diaz as a bro? Again horrible comparison. That is like saying Lewis beat Bowe as an amateur. But, Bowe could of won against Lewis as a pro. But, yet Bowe ducked Lewis as a pro.

wrong again that is called an example to show how the amateur and pro games differ and that just because you beat someone in the amateurs doesnt mean your a better pro boxer did zab fight diaz as a pro and if he did would diaz have been the fav? anyone with common sense can see what im getting at i guess you dont have any.

[DiLLiNGER]

Beating someone in the amateurs aint the same as the pros...ask Mark Breland

I hope you aren't siding with the thread starter...

Nice av pic,hope u dont mind me stealing it

Forget about this thread,the TS received bad brain damage when gabriel gonzaga landed that nice KO'ing head kick on the head of his.

[jrosales13]

wrong again that is called an example to show how the amateur and pro games differ and that just because you beat someone in the amateurs doesnt mean your a better pro boxer did zab fight diaz as a pro and if he did would diaz have been the fav? anyone with common sense can see what im getting at i guess you dont have any.

But, who would of won? So you win fights on paper now? You don't win the fights in the ring no more? On paper Zab beats Baldomir on the ring who won? Yea you are wrong again.

[-EX-]

You put Spadafora as an example which was a bad example. The point of this argument was that Judah should of not had a title when he fought Floyd. Cuz he lost to Baldomir. NY made cameback with saying well Diaz was the weakest. Zab has more skills than David. But, you can't compare cuz Diaz was a legit title holder who was undefeated as a LW. While Zab was coming of a lose. What side are you taking bro?

I aint arguing against that...

I'm jus saying just cuz Diaz beat Judah in the amateurs, doesn't mean he'd beat him in the pros...perfect example=Cotto-Abdullaev