Is CALZAGHE the most OVERRATED Hall Of Famer in the HISTORY of BOXING?

[LEFTYGUNZZ]

he is a future hall of famer.

Well let us just wait till he gets voted in okay my friend? Ask a question that makes sense or is based on some truth like:

Is CALZAGHE the most OVERRATED FUTURE Hall Of Famer in the HISTORY of BOXING?

There I fixed it for ya....Lefty

[Adamantium]

Go ahead and try to name one fighter thats more overrated than Calzaghe.

I admit I cant, but being overrated isnt necessarily a bad thing, it just means your not as good as people think you are. But that doesnt mean you are not good.

[SplitSecond]

I admit I cant, but being overrated isnt necessarily a bad thing, it just means your not as good as people think you are. But that doesnt mean you are not good.

my thoughts exactly
good post

[TheCheetah]

I don't think he should be in the hall of fame. I don't care about his undefeated record.. When he fights someone other than washed up fighters let me know.

[SplitSecond]

Joe Calzaghe will be a hall of famer. And I will agree he belongs there.

Remember that Hopkins destroyed a young prime Pavlik and gave Jermaine a good fight twice. Beat down Winky Wright, a man that's not easy to hit.

Sure, styles make fights, but he beat Hopkins. A win is a win. There was no controversy there. As for RJJ, yeah, he was passed his prime (Joe was no spring chicken either). But he took the fight anyway. Props to the old man RJJ for taking the fight.

lets not forget that joe won that fight against hopkins by as much as taylor against hopkins

as for wright, what you expect when he had to jump up like that?
pavlik has always been crap, only fools that cant see styles for what they are thought he'd win
and the reason i think calzaghe will be in the hall of fame is because of his undefeated record(crap as it may be) and ruling the history lacking supermiddleweight division

[1SILVA]

He hasn't been inducted yet

[TRAVI$]

If you had a spare braincell, you'd know that even though Joe's resume is weak... he was a brilliant boxer, would be a nightmare for any past fighter from 168-175.

[LEFTYGUNZZ]

He hasn't been inducted yet

But he will be based upon his awesome destruction of Peter Manfreddo. I mean look at the thunderous shot landed forcing the reff to stop the action....Lefty

[TRAVI$]

Calzaghe wasn't the best fighter in close, but "slapping" was better than doing nothing or clinching.

[Pullcounter]

I think he is. Calzaghe !!

who says he's in the HOF?