Is CALZAGHE the most OVERRATED Hall Of Famer in the HISTORY of BOXING?

[Sir Tom Jones]

no. its just my opinion really.

keep it to yourself next time dutchie boy.

[J.Dempsey]

I think calzaghes good, took him a while to break America coz of other issues IMO, he's undefeated n not afraid to fight in the ring, I don't think he's overrated too much

[Grand Champ]

No. ....................

[LEFTYGUNZZ]

I think he is. Calzaghe !!

Calzaghe is a good figher. had a tough style to deal with for alot of people. Punches in volume and early on in his career when most people on this side of the pond didn't know who the hell he was he had some power. As far as hall of famer. When did he get into the hall of fame....Lefty

[wXh.]

You just hate white fighters. You and that other loser whose name eludes me atm are really becoming very tiring with your broken record repetitive posts.

No thats not true. I got nothing against Hatton and Kessler. I like Abraham and Gatti.

[Hyde]

Joe Calzaghe is BY FAR the most overrated fighter of all time. He was a FRAUD. for a supposed hall of famer he has the worst resume. Imo Joe Calzaghe doesn't deserve to get in the HOF.

His resume is absolutley horrible.

past prime 44 year old Hopkins who he arguably lost to.
a shot 40 year old roy jones jr
a hyped up c level fighter Jeff Lacy
another hyped up c level fighter Mikkell Kessler
a weight drained past prime Chris Eubank

His best and most career defining win was against Mikkell Kessler. WHAT A ****IN JOKE. Kessler got beaten up way worse by a green 25 year old Andre Ward. And this was supposed to be his best win? LMFAO.

Joe Calzaghe was a coward and a fraud. He spent 10 years defending a ****ty WBO paper title in his backyard against bums like Mario Veit(x2) or Mkrtchyan. He was AFRAID to go to america and fight the best like a PRIME Hopkins or a PRIME Roy Jones jr or even Tarver, Johnson and Dawson. and theres a reason for that. He knows he would have gotten his ass whooped.

Joe Calzaghe is no better than Sven Ottke or Zsolt Erdei. But the absolutley delusional slappy fanboys think he is some sort of all time great simply because he is undeafeted. Being Undeafeted means NOTHING when you have such a terrible resume like Calzaghe does. Sven Ottke had 21 title defences and retired undeafeted just like slappy so I guess he is an all time great to huh? AHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH.

a shot 40 year old Roy Jones Jr knocked him down and had him seriously hurt in the first round, what do you think a PRIME Roy would have done? I'll tell you he would have ended it right there.

Calzaghe's resume is a joke compared to Roy Jones jr or Bernard Hopkins.

B-hop's resume:

Felix Trinidad
Oscar De La Hoya
Kelly Pavlik
Antonio Tarver
Winky Wright
William Joppy

RJJ's resume:

Bernard Hopkins
James Toney
Mike McCallum
John Ruiz
Antonio Tarver
Montell Griffin

If Joe Calzaghe wasn't undeafeted he would be NOTHING. He wouldn't even be named in the same sentence as real legends like Bernard Hopkins or Roy Jones Jr. He got two split decisions against Robin Reid and Bernard Hopkins, it could easily have been 2 losses. If Joe Calzaghe had the guts to go to america earlier in his career and faced the best he would have SEVERAL losses. Without that "0" slappy is NOTHING.

Joe Calzaghe also has one of the most ugliest styles of all time. It looks PATHETIC. it looks like a girl fighting. He can't even throw a REAL punch. I bet the female welterweight champion of the world Holly Holm punches twice as hard as joe slapzaghe.

Joe Calzaghe was an absolute JOKE, a FRAUD and a bad rolemodel for kids. He was a DISGRACE for boxing.

[wXh.]

Calzaghe is a good figher. had a tough style to deal with for alot of people. Punches in volume and early on in his career when most people on this side of the pond didn't know who the hell he was he had some power. As far as hall of famer. When did he get into the hall of fame....Lefty

he is a future hall of famer.

[wXh.]

Joe Calzaghe is BY FAR the most overrated fighter of all time. He was a FRAUD. for a supposed hall of famer he has the worst resume. Imo Joe Calzaghe doesn't deserve to get in the HOF.

His resume is absolutley horrible.

past prime 44 year old Hopkins who he arguably lost to.
a shot 40 year old roy jones jr
a hyped up c level fighter Jeff Lacy
another hyped up c level fighter Mikkell Kessler
a weight drained past prime Chris Eubank

His best and most career defining win was against Mikkell Kessler. WHAT A ****IN JOKE. Kessler got beaten up way worse by a green 25 year old Andre Ward. And this was supposed to be his best win? LMFAO.

Joe Calzaghe was a coward and a fraud. He spent 10 years defending a ****ty WBO paper title in his backyard against bums like Mario Veit(x2) or Mkrtchyan. He was AFRAID to go to america and fight the best like a PRIME Hopkins or a PRIME Roy Jones jr or even Tarver, Johnson and Dawson. and theres a reason for that. He knows he would have gotten his ass whooped.

Joe Calzaghe is no better than Sven Ottke or Zsolt Erdei. But the absolutley delusional slappy fanboys think he is some sort of all time great simply because he is undeafeted. Being Undeafeted means NOTHING when you have such a terrible resume like Calzaghe does. Sven Ottke had 21 title defences and retired undeafeted just like slappy so I guess he is an all time great to huh? AHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH.

a shot 40 year old Roy Jones Jr knocked him down and had him seriously hurt in the first round, what do you think a PRIME Roy would have done? I'll tell you he would have ended it right there.

Calzaghe's resume is a joke compared to Roy Jones jr or Bernard Hopkins.

B-hop's resume:

Felix Trinidad
Oscar De La Hoya
Kelly Pavlik
Antonio Tarver
Winky Wright
William Joppy

RJJ's resume:

Bernard Hopkins
James Toney
Mike McCallum
John Ruiz
Antonio Tarver
Montell Griffin

If Joe Calzaghe wasn't undeafeted he would be NOTHING. He wouldn't even be named in the same sentence as real legends like Bernard Hopkins or Roy Jones Jr. He got two split decisions against Robin Reid and Bernard Hopkins, it could easily have been 2 losses. If Joe Calzaghe had the guts to go to america earlier in his career and faced the best he would have SEVERAL losses. Without that "0" slappy is NOTHING.

Joe Calzaghe also has one of the most ugliest styles of all time. It looks PATHETIC. it looks like a girl fighting. He can't even throw a REAL punch. I bet the female welterweight champion of the world Holly Holm punches twice as hard as joe slapzaghe.

Joe Calzaghe was an absolute JOKE, a FRAUD and a bad rolemodel for kids. He was a DISGRACE for boxing.

word. couldnt agree more.

[Adamantium]

Joe Calzaghe is BY FAR the most overrated fighter of all time.

Im sure there has to be someone else more overrated than Joe, im also sure that Joe would make a top 110 atg list.

[Hyde]

Im sure thats has to be someone else more overrated than Joe, im also sure that Joe would make a top 110 atg list.

Go ahead and try to name one fighter thats more overrated than Calzaghe.