A Showdown Looms: BoxingScene’s Pound for Pound Top Ten

**Joeyzagz** · 11-23-2009, 02:12 AM

Why the hell is Cotto on that list?

Id put David Haye, and all of the early leaders of the Super Six before Cotto.

**shadeyfizzle** · 11-23-2009, 02:19 AM

I would love to see Nonito Donaire vs Hozumi Hasegawa. That would be one hell of a fight.

**Tha_Greatest** · 11-23-2009, 02:23 AM

any klitchko belongs higher than p.williams dawson, marquez or cotto

**leemoorcroft** · 11-23-2009, 02:26 AM

rather dodgey p4p top ten that hopkins aint even fought this year to be 3rd mosley 1 fight vitali klitchko should be there and put even amir khan above cotto his performance against clottey was very moody and took a huge beat down by pac leaveing jennings the only real win hes had since margartio beat him down khan has beat barrera and kotlenik and soon to be salita i would even put jones jr above cotto or ward judgeing by his win over kessler

**Tha_Greatest** · 11-23-2009, 02:27 AM

Originally posted by Soir

Why the hell is Cotto on that list?

Id put David Haye, and all of the early leaders of the Super Six before Cotto.

id put hopkins and mosley ahead of floyd anyday of the week, floyd has to be downgraded like my fellow mexicans r.marquez and i. vasquez for inactivity and cherrypicking

**Tha_Greatest** · 11-23-2009, 02:29 AM

Originally posted by leemoorcroft

rather dodgey p4p top ten that hopkins aint even fought this year to be 3rd mosley 1 fight vitali klitchko should be there and put even amir khan above cotto his performance against clottey was very moody and took a huge beat down by pac leaveing jennings the only real win hes had since margartio beat him down khan has beat barrera and kotlenik and soon to be salita i would even put jones jr above cotto or ward judgeing by his win over kessler

im no vitali fan but ive never seem to have seen him in any american top 10 p4p list, ive seen rahman and toney on theirbefore but never any klitschko,

**Tha_Greatest** · 11-23-2009, 02:32 AM

Originally posted by BIGPOPPAPUMP

By Cliff Rold - Pacquiao.

Mayweather.

Everyone else.

That’s the equation in boxing right now, economically and meritoriously. They are not the only great fighters of their time, but they stand above the crowd as the most accomplished, prime prize fighters of the day. It is rare that two such fighters hit the scale at the same size. [details]

this list is a piece of ****, biased piece of garbage p4p list of all time, i wouldnt be shocked if berto is soon in the list

berto is the worst champ in any division

**#4#king** · 11-23-2009, 02:38 AM

Originally posted by Soir

Why the hell is Cotto on that list?

Id put David Haye, and all of the early leaders of the Super Six before Cotto.

because cotto is a world-class boxer who just lost in an exciting fight to one of the most electrifying boxers in recent memory...haye is a decent boxer fighting boring fights against mediocre to below average boxers in a weight class he shouldnt be fighting at in the first place...

you could make an argument for abraham over cotto, sure...ward still has more to prove, and froch...well...no...

people put way too much stock into undefeated records in boxing...sure, cotto lost convincingly...twice...but he's still an elite boxer, and is deserving of a top 10 p4p ranking IMO...

**#4#king** · 11-23-2009, 02:41 AM

Originally posted by shadeyfizzle

I would love to see Nonito Donaire vs Hozumi Hasegawa. That would be one hell of a fight.

touche brother...

A Showdown Looms: BoxingScene’s Pound for Pound Top Ten