Paul Williams - the most overrated of his generation?

[firstborn]

How can Quintana be PWill daddy when PWill KO'd is ass! Yeah Quintana won the first fight by decision but the KO victory proved that PWill learned from his mistakes in the first fight. Does anyone know if Quintana even wants a shot at redemption?

If PWill is so over hyped can you explain why Pavlik ducked hiim and Clottey made up a bunch of excuses, even though he was already training for a fight on the same date as PWill.

[Blue Heffner]

How is he over rated and people are unwilling to fight him? And it's clear he's willing to fight anyone? No fighter who's willing to fight anyone at 3 different weights is over rated.

[RockyB]

he may be overrated, but for all we know he can be a GREAT fighter, but if it keeps on as it is now, we will never know since nobody wants to fight him..

[TheSurgeonMDMPH]

Cause those guys dont want to get in the ring with him.
Clottey turned down a fight, Pavlik postponed the fight twice due to an infection, and once Williams signed another fight, he signed a fight for two weeks past their original date and the Mosley, who apparently will fight anyone, has been called out by Williams several tiems with no response.

its obvious that the majority of PW critics are fan boys of fighters who blatantly duck him. u probably should just ignore the ignorant. they tend to go away after awhile.

[Princemanspopa]

How can Quintana be PWill daddy when PWill KO'd is ass! Yeah Quintana won the first fight by decision but the KO victory proved that PWill learned from his mistakes in the first fight. Does anyone know if Quintana even wants a shot at redemption?.

Yes he does want a rematch.After Quintana schooled him over twelve rounds and beat him in decisive fashion,he didn't have to give Williams a rematch,but he did anyway and Paul Williams got a lucky night.How do we know that Williams learned from his mistakes? He did nothing to Quintana that proves that he has or improved as a fighter.

How is he over rated and people are unwilling to fight him? And it's clear he's willing to fight anyone? No fighter who's willing to fight anyone at 3 different weights is over rated.

He's overrated because he doesn't deserve the hype that he is getting.He has beaten two top fighters in his career and some idiots still believe that he would beat anybody within the 147-160 range even though he already lost a clear decision to Carlos Quintana.

You've been told by the media that Williams is being avoided and you and many other gullible boxing fans believe that he is.

its obvious that the majority of PW critics are fan boys of fighters who blatantly duck him. u probably should just ignore the ignorant. they tend to go away after awhile.

Speaking of ignorant,most fans of fighters wouldn't give their favourite fighter such great credit for beating an old,rusty fighter who hadn't fought in nearly two years...but all seven of Paul Williams fans do.

[Pugilistic™]

Quintana is his daddy ?



First round KO > 12 round UD.

[Princemanspopa]

Quintana is his daddy ?



First round KO > 12 round UD.

You are sadly mistaken.A first round KO may appeal to the casual fanbase who know nothing about boxing,but true fans of the sport know that a twelve round schooling is far greater than a simple one round blowout.We learned alot more about both Williams and Quintana as fighters than we did in their rematch.


Quintana gave Williams a rematch....where's Quintana's rematch?

[Bushbaby]

Do not confuse overrated with under appreciated,baby!!If all top fighters had his mentality boxing would still be on top of the world!!Right now,there are superstar fighters who don't fight in their own div!!The only fighter under 160 besides the Punisher that will get in the ring with anyone is Cotto,but he luckily has a huge fanbase!!But Cotto's fanbase are also full of hypocrites who **** on floyd for ducking fighters but ride the nutts of Juanma,go figure!!

[Pugilistic™]

You are sadly mistaken.A first round KO may appeal to the casual fanbase who know nothing about boxing,but true fans of the sport know that a twelve round schooling is far greater than a simple one round blowout.We learned alot more about both Williams and Quintana as fighters than we did in their rematch.


Quintana gave Williams a rematch....where's Quintana's rematch?

A schooling ?

Quintana did win clearly but it wasn't exactly a schooling.

So according to your logic Max Schmeling's 12th round KO over Louis was more impressive than Joe louis 1st round KO over Schmeling ? You have strange logic.

how about another example, imagine Pacquiao fighting Cotto on November 14th and lets say he wins a clear decision.......... then imagine him winning via first round KO....... Whats more impressive ?

[IMDAZED]

Ricky Hatton?

Zab Judah?