Canelo is not an all time great fighter

[djtmal]

Hof yes

P4p all he is so low it's not worth talking about

[SouthpawRight]

Saul was P4P King

All Time Greatness

1. Saul
2. JUAN
3. Erik
4. Marco

but manny didn't dare try Saul

[IronDanHamza]

The level is cope is sad

Canelo was the P4P #1 fighter in the sport for 4 years. Top 10 for 12 years and counting.

4 weight world champion, two of which Lineal and one of which undisputed.

Name another fighter in history who has credentials even remotely similar to this that isn’t an ATG.

[Grandma Lover]

He really isn't. Debating it isn't even hard.

Got gifts against lara, 2 golovkin fights, and some people say trout (i think he won't close but clear).

All the big name fighters he fought were shot. Mosley, froid (who probably was on steroids but maybe carnela too), kovalev who just got rocked by a prime yarde like a month before fighting him and baldimor who was decent at best.


Its like the people on here are allergic to facts and context.

[Mimms]

Hof yes

P4p all he is so low it's not worth talking about

Mexicans need 20 Modelos to handle this fact

[TheProudLunatic]

Hof yes

P4p all he is so low it's not worth talking about

Some resumes are inflated
Others are mocked
A scant few are given the credit they deserve

Marciano = Garbage resume
Gatti = GTFOH
GGG = Pure garbage ("That run, doe !")
Ali = Only a hater can say he doesn't have the best HW resume of all time
Guys like DLH, Mosley, Holy, K2 = Legit AF
Old Timey Guys = Great compilers. So many bartenders, bouncers and cabdrivers pretending to be boxers.
Mike Tyson = Garbage

So called fight fans pick and choose which resumes are quality.
Does it pain a MFer to put their biases aside and deal with ACTUAL FACTS ?!?!?

Is Guy A's resume better than Guys B-???

"I'm a fan of this guy so no resume is better than his !!!"
FOH

Matching future HOFers with other future HOFers, in their primes, is not an everyday occurrence.
In order to be an ATG, one must have the opportunity to face the best, and NOT just the best "at the moment"

"He was "ranked" "
Big ****ing Deal
Let's never forget Bruce Seldon was once a champ and that Mario Cherrios IS "a" "champ"
A ranked fighter OR champ has to be legit.

Nelo's resume is a lot better than some unnamed guys who is are fan favorites

[moochi]

Of course not.

All of his step ups he lost. His best wins are losses as well lol.
Then his legitimate best wins are well timed against washed ups and C grade Brits.

[TheProudLunatic]

Of course not.

All of his step ups he lost. His best wins are losses as well lol.
Then his legitimate best wins are well timed against washed ups and C grade Brits.

During his time, who has a better resume ?

[Coverdale]

Yes he is. Stop trying to provoke silly arguments to pass your time. Try writing something insightful.

[djtmal]

. Try writing something insightful.

jump off a bridge