Demetrius Andrade would had schooled Canelo too.

[MalevolentBite]

Canelo would've beat the **** out of Andrade..

Damn..... ok. The only person I remember Canelo really beating down was when he faced a faded fighter but ok. Fair enough.

[dan_cov]

Mayweather, Bivol, Crawford & Lara are much better boxers than Andrade.

With Andrade I think while it is a bad match up for Canelo in some sense but at the same time one where he'd eventually track down Andrade and stop him.
I think its sort of similar to Plant, BJS, etc where he has real problems with their movement but he makes too many mistakes and frankly doesn't have the defence or durability to withstand the inevitable. I think Canelo would find him eventually and get him out of there. Maybe trailing at the time

[dan_cov]

Andrade is boring.

To Canelo's credit he fought Mayweather, Trout, Lara, Crawford, BJS, Bivol (granted I think this was a cherrypick that went wrong) he has fought a lot of guys who are wrong for him stylistically. Even guys like Plant to a degree.
No two fights are the same but its hard for me to say its a duck when he has fought and beat what are essentially better versions, the guy IS boring af, he has beaten nobody and he has no fan base. Truth is Andrade brings nothing to the table.
If Canelo did fight him he'd get no credit. Nobody cared for that fight but maybe 10 hardcore fans who speculated Andrade was this and that based on little more than him fighting domestic level opposition in which he was hurt/dropped or struggled vs multiple times

[drablj]

That's fair ^

So who would win at 154, 160 or 168?

we can't know that but canelo would be the favourite. callum smith was considered a bigger threat than saunders (taller, longer, harder punch) but it was an easy fight for canelo after 1 round. canelo tried that same plan (destroying one arm) with bivol and it backfired. bivol was confused and pointed out afterwards that his arm hurts and everything else was easy. saunders had some success until one punch changed everything. andrade was at the similar level as saunders then but longer and more disciplined (no ballooning to heavyweight between fights). if canelo's plan wasn't working, andrade had a chance to win. also, andrade would be highly motivated and try to have the best camp of his life for this fight. i doubt he would quit like when he faced 8 years younger, bigger and relentless opponent for much less money.

too many variables to predict the result for sure. i just want them to fight the fights. it doesn't matter who wins. none of them are my friends and family and they will never care about my existence. i am in it for the sport only.

[RockyKO]

That would be an interesting fight now. Andrade hasn't fought in 2 years and Canelo's power is fading rapidly. It would be fun to see if Canelo can overwhelm him with his strength or if Andrade is unconventional enough to give him problems. I could be wrong but those 2 styles might mesh really well. Get on it Al Haymon!

[paulf]

Andrade's best win was a SD over a washed Vanes Martirosyan. Feather-fisted Vanes dropped him.

What on earth are you talking about????

[TheIronMike]

No he wouldn't have, this guy never beat any world class fighter and struggled with Liam Williams, Andrade is a C level fighter throwing that amateurish bolo uppercut.

Canelo's best non-judge influenced win is Caleb Plant bruh

[MalevolentBite]

Mayweather, Bivol, Crawford & Lara are much better boxers than Andrade.

With Andrade I think while it is a bad match up for Canelo in some sense but at the same time one where he'd eventually track down Andrade and stop him.
I think its sort of similar to Plant, BJS, etc where he has real problems with their movement but he makes too many mistakes and frankly doesn't have the defence or durability to withstand the inevitable. I think Canelo would find him eventually and get him out of there. Maybe trailing at the time

To be fair BJS ducked Demetrius Andrade at 160 and ran to 168. That wasnt the best version of BJS. Plant was a good boxer. Idk know if I can say BJS is better than Demetrius Andrade because he ducked alot of people himself. But I respect your analysis

[MalevolentBite]

Andrade's best win was a SD over a washed Vanes Martirosyan. Feather-fisted Vanes dropped him.

What on earth are you talking about????

Whats canelos best win ? A robbery over GGG? A faded cotto ? Or a faded Kovalev? I will wait.

[MalevolentBite]

Canelo's best non-judge influenced win is Caleb Plant bruh

Even that doesnt really hold up that well lol.