Comments Thread For: Spare a thought for David Benavidez

[TheProudLunatic]

you’re mentally ill

Most excellent rebuttal !

On paper
Berlanga > 90% of everyone Benny beat.

Why do you think his fan(s) are so reluctant to give his resume a rating ?

[TheProudLunatic]

As a show of Benny's impressive resume, there are tons of threads dedicated to it

Oh, wait.......

[SouthpawRight]

Nelo is just 1 fight

Again, if Nelo never existed, what rating would you give Benny's resume ?

what level fighter is Benavidez

I think about that Keith Thurman level

[TheProudLunatic]

what level fighter is Benavidez

I think about that Keith Thurman level

Sometime's resume crushes Benny's
It's easy to look unbeatable when your opps are pitiful.

[Oregonian]

My scenario isn't that far fetched
They may never fight
Hence

I know why there is extreme reluctance to give Benny's resume a rating !

--------------------------------------------

You are right. Your scenario is not that far fetched. What you are trying to do is trying to discredit Benny as a credible mandatory to Canelo. You assume that there is a reluctance on people to give Benny's resume a rating. We don't have to. Benny's resume next to Canelo is trash. That does not mean Benny was not Canelo's mandatory. It does not mean Munguia, Charlo, Ryder, Scull and Berlanga were the better option for Canelo. It just means Canelo did not want to fight Benny for obvious reasons.

Tank Davis' last 5 opponents were Lamont Roach, Frank Martin, Ryan Garcia, Hector Luiz Garcia and Rolando Romero. When we say he is DUCKING Shakur, guys like you will ask us "If Tank never existed, rate Shakur's resume.Why is this so difficult"

So with that context, are you going to discredit Shakur as a legit threat to Tank because he has a weaker resume? If your answer is yes then there is no point in debating Benny's resume because Canelo ducked him.

[TheProudLunatic]

--------------------------------------------

You are right. Your scenario is not that far fetched. What you are trying to do is trying to discredit Benny as a credible mandatory to Canelo. You assume that there is a reluctance on people to give Benny's resume a rating. We don't have to.

Ok, then