Manny WOULD Be the GOAT Had He Ultimately Defeat Juan & Take Floyd’s 0

[SouthpawRight]

In this alternate reality manny vanquishes his main rival + beats the smartest boxer ever, the boxing god of clean punching

[Grandma Lover]

But he did beat Juan and Mayweather was on steroids

[SouthpawRight]

If Pacquaio beat Mayweather he would be the #1 ATG for me.

No question about it either at that point.

1. Sugar Robinson
2. Harry Greb possibly top slot if we had fight footage
3. Henry Armstrong midget beating up bigger man
4. Sam Langford short guy beating up tall heavyweights
5. Muhammad Ali
6. Ezzard Charles as a young man whooped both Charley Burley and Archie Moore who are among the most skilled technicians ever
7. Roberto Duran
8. Joe Louis
9. Willie Pep
10. Sugar Leonard
11. Floyd king of clean punching and god of defense

manny is somewhere in the top 15

But he did beat Juan and Mayweather was on steroids

Juan had the last laugh in their tetralogy and used steroids to even out the playing field against manny

[SouthpawRight]

Right but Pacquaio’s current position, resume and achievements added with a win over an undefeated, P4P #1 Mayweather would have put him #1, on my list.

crazy to see how close Floyd and Manny were in the race

being the wide winner of their fight gives Floyd clear lead

[hugh grant]

Floyd was 3 divisions bigger naturally. He was supposed to best pac. Hagler beat duran, and no harm done to Durans legacy, he's still greater than hagler and hearns.
Pac s best of era.

[famicommander]

If Frank Bruno had beaten Bonecrusher, Terrible Tim, Mike Tyson twice, and Lennox Lewis he'd be one of the greatest heavyweights ever.

But he didn't do any of that, so who cares?

Manny's already an all time great. No reason to make up fantasy scenarios.

[SouthpawRight]

Floyd was 3 divisions bigger naturally. He was supposed to best pac. Hagler beat duran, and no harm done to Durans legacy, he's still greater than hagler and hearns.
Pac s best of era.

[hugh grant]

Hearns humiliated duran, knocked duran face down. Duran still greater. You know where im.going with this. Floyd tip tapped pac to a controversial decision. Pacs still greater than floyd

[MalevolentBite]

If manny some how beaten canelo at 154lb and then took Floyd's 0. He would be the Goat, now if you add him beating Crawford at 147 after beating Thurman. He would take Ali or SSR spot bar none.

[daggum]

if he had gotten the decision against a 38 year old floyd who had been cherry picking for years and years to artificially extend his career he would be the greatest? dont think so and i scored that fight for pac since he was the one landing all the clean punches with leverage and body weight while floyd was leaning away, off balance, had no leverage on on all his shots because he extended himself too much while leaning back and this naturally resulted in a lot of grazes, misses and light touches instead of clean punches like pac was landing. this is why its so detrimental to duck fighters. no one gets an accurate beat on who is actually good and who isnt. if someone beats innoue right now. no one is saying well he was old and cherry picking. castillo beat a better version of floyd. hes not the greatest. an over the hill pac beat an over the hill floyd. not bad but ironically it doesnt mean that much just like floyds wins over all those old guys dont mean that much.