Who is greater all time: Pac or Duran

[hugh grant]

Roberto is arguably the goat lightweight

manny made no case for being the goat of any weight

Roberto beat his version of Floyd, Sugar Leonard

manny fumbled hard when faced with his version of Sugar Leonard, Floyd, who won by wide decision and stayed in first gear the entire time

manny didn’t live up to the hype of being THE MEDIA CHOSEN ONE to get Floyd lol

Pac not goat of any weight? What's that mean? If pac campaigned in just one weight he would be goat of that weight.
Duran.lost 2 out of 3 with srl..Just like Floyd would of if he dared give rematches

[hugh grant]

Roberto getting a PRIME Sugar Leonard could be the biggest win ever in boxing

Sugar Leonard is top 10 atg

How about Randolph turpin beating srr? Is he greater than pac or duran!

[SouthpawRight]

Pac not goat of any weight? What's that mean? If pac campaigned in just one weight he would be goat of that weight.
Duran.lost 2 out of 3 with srl..Just like Floyd would of if he dared give rematches

but manny did not campaign long enough in any weight to come close to be the goat of any division

yes Floyd only dared to give rematches to opponents who did good by taking at least 4 rounds Jose Luis Marcos

manny managed to take only 2 to 3 rounds and looked like a hypejob when faced with Floyd lol

How about Randolph turpin beating srr? Is he greater than pac or duran!

different circumstances

Roberto was a smaller man coming up to Sugar Leonard's weight

Randy was the bigger man facing a Sugar Robinson who came up to his weight

beyond the Sugar fights Roberto did great and has vastly superior all around work to Randy

Roberto is a top 10 all time

Randy is not an all time

[hugh grant]

but manny did not campaign long enough in any weight to come close to be the goat of any division

yes Floyd only dared to give rematches to opponents who did good by taking at least 4 rounds Jose Luis Marcos

manny managed to take only 2 to 3 rounds and looked like a hypejob when faced with Floyd lol
different circumstances

Roberto was a smaller man coming up to Sugar Leonard's weight

You can't use duran.losing two out of 3 fights to srl as evidence to be better than pac on technicality that floyd daren't give pac rematch as floyd knew he'd lose 2 out of 3 fights with pac, and pac had one arm.? And pac wasn't smaller than floyd was he? Nobody cares how many rounds floyd beat pac by, it doesn't mean he'd win a rematch.

I'm not saying duran isnt greater than pac. But duran wouldn't be greater for the reasons your suggesting, as what your saying isn't making sense

[TheProudLunatic]

Pacquiao has wins over greats like barrera marquez and morales…cotto…
Duran has a win over Sugar ray… i like Duran.. but his resume doesn’t run as deep as pacquiao’s.. he was an extremely dominant at 135lbs.. but who did he beat there really?

he hanged against the fab 4 seems to be where he gets the benefit of the doubt… im sure he can compete at any era. But resume wise.. pacquiao clears him.

Barrera, JMM and Morales = Perfect Pac opps.
The kinds who stand and trade
Not fleet of foot nor hand
JMM had Pac's number
I can't see the Marco or Erik Pac fought (or any version) troubling PBF
Obviously May didn't need more than 1 fight with JMM

Cotto lite shouldn't count
Pac wouldn't give him a no clause rematch !!!
Pac had a way of fighting guys at their worst !

Can you imagine the catchweights Pac would use on Hagler, Hearns, SRL ?!?

Pac's resume is weak AF if a person is an honest fight fan.
8 div fraud

[Joe Beamish]

Duran. Who’s the best opponent that Pac defeated? Anything close to prime Leonard? No? GTFO here

[RuleOfTheSpear]

Pac has the edge in terms of quantity wins against HOF'ers (2x Barrera, 2x Morales, 2x Marquez, Dela Hoya, Hatton, Cotto, Mosley, 2x Bradley)
Duran has the edge in terms of quality wins against HOF'ers (Buchanan, Palomino, Leonard, Cuevas)


If you think about it, their records would look identical if Pac were to beat Floyd but lose to Dela Hoya, Cotto, and Mosley/Margarito, or something.
If you were to flip it, would Duran be as great if he never beat Leonard but beat Hearns, Hagler, Benitez, etc.? I think so.


It really depends on what you prefer.
Having one big win in your entire record but fell short against others
OR
Having a collection of named scalps except that big one

Some people prefer depth.
Some people prefer variety.

[SouthpawRight]

You can't use duran.losing two out of 3 fights to srl as evidence to be better than pac on technicality that floyd daren't give pac rematch as floyd knew he'd lose 2 out of 3 fights with pac, and pac had one arm.? And pac wasn't smaller than floyd was he? Nobody cares how many rounds floyd beat pac by, it doesn't mean he'd win a rematch.

I'm not saying duran isnt greater than pac. But duran wouldn't be greater for the reasons your suggesting, as what your saying isn't making sense

Barrera, JMM and Morales = Perfect Pac opps.
The kinds who stand and trade
Not fleet of foot nor hand
JMM had Pac's number
I can't see the Marco or Erik Pac fought (or any version) troubling PBF
Obviously May didn't need more than 1 fight with JMM

Cotto lite shouldn't count
Pac wouldn't give him a no clause rematch !!!
Pac had a way of fighting guys at their worst !

Can you imagine the catchweights Pac would use on Hagler, Hearns, SRL ?!?

Pac's resume is weak AF if a person is an honest fight fan.
8 div fraud

get a load of this FAN FICTION by hugh

Pac has the edge in terms of quantity wins against HOF'ers (2x Barrera, 2x Morales, 2x Marquez, Dela Hoya, Hatton, Cotto, Mosley, 2x Bradley)
Duran has the edge in terms of quality wins against HOF'ers (Buchanan, Palomino, Leonard, Cuevas)


If you think about it, their records would look identical if Pac were to beat Floyd but lose to Dela Hoya, Cotto, and Mosley/Margarito, or something.
If you were to flip it, would Duran be as great if he never beat Leonard but beat Hearns, Hagler, Benitez, etc.? I think so.


It really depends on what you prefer.
Having one big win in your entire record but fell short against others
OR
Having a collection of named scalps except that big one

Some people prefer depth.
Some people prefer variety.

H2H

Roberto is among the most skilled ever

On his best day better than manny’s best day

But due to No Mas also much worse than manny on their worst days

manny had the benefit of tactical matchmaking and was able to face Miguel Shane and marg at their most vulnerable lowest points

[TheProudLunatic]

get a load of this FAN FICTION by hugh

H2H

Roberto is among the most skilled ever

On his best day better than manny’s best day

But due to No Mas also much worse than manny on their worst days

manny had the benefit of tactical matchmaking and was able to face Miguel Shane and marg at their most vulnerable lowest points

Fan fiction is a superpower with those fools
Duran would end Pac's life.

[SouthpawRight]

Fan fiction is a superpower with those fools
Duran would end Pac's life.

Roberto higher level at his very best

beat prime Sugar Leonard

took 6 rounds from top 3 all time middleweight Marvin who is a top 20 p4p all time

Roberto 8-4 manny or stops him if it’s a 15 rounder