Who is greater all time: Pac or Duran

[SouthpawRight]

Sasakul missing from Pacquaio’s list.

Margarito, Broner, Matthysee, Rios, Vargas I’d remove from Pacquaio’s list.

Vargas Horn Lucas Broner was manny’s cherry spree

and it worked

those two easy years limited the punishment allowing manny to prolong his career

ultimately achieving longevity

[hugh grant]

Vargas Horn Lucas Broner was manny’s cherry spree

and it worked

those two easy years limited the punishment allowing manny to prolong his career

ultimately achieving longevity

Did floyd request CW with.nelo, as he wanted to prolong his career another 10 years, like pac did with cotto? No, it was more to keep zero, floyd was getting out of sport ASAP

[eco1]

There isn't really a debate here. A quitter cannot be higher than Manny all time.

A quitter because Omar Torrijos's brother bet against him in the second fight?

That is what truly happened.

[Boxing 112]

A quitter because Omar Torrijos's brother bet against him in the second fight?

That is what truly happened.

That doesn't make it any better even IF that was true. Quitter.

[gauze]

Esteban DeJesus is in the HOF, so is Ken Buchanan who you left out. A long with a list of Top 5-10 ranked Lightweights.

Cuevas and Palomino as you mentioned, two top WW’s.

He beat Davey Moore in his at Jr Middlweight, after starting his career as a Bantamweight, as a big underdog to win that belt.

And then of course he beat an undefeated Sugar Ray Leonard.

So to ask “who did he beat” is just a very wild thing to ask.

i am pretty sure esteban is not in the IBHOF. actually, looking at the list of inductees on the IBHOF website, it seems kind of small. if you've ever been to canastota and have read every single plaque on the wall, you'd think there were way more inductees. you could spend hours and hours in that little museum!

dejesus is in some halls of fame, but not that one, to my knowledge. he should be in there. i would guess he's not due to the controversies outside the ring.

davey moore has some good wins over ayub kalule and wilfred benitez, and good shout out on ken buchanan. i'm certainly not saying duran is a bum and never beat anyone, i just think pacquiao has accomplished more and there might be some bias since i watched his career in real-time.

i do think head to head at 135 or 147 it's a hell of a match-up that could go either way

[eco1]

That doesn't make it any better even IF that was true. Quitter.

Let someone tell you you and your whole family are done if you don't follow the steps and we shall see...Bigmouth

[NarcosMaidana]

Vargas Horn Lucas Broner was manny’s cherry spree

and it worked

those two easy years limited the punishment allowing manny to prolong his career

ultimately achieving longevity

El Chino disagree.

Jesse Vargas was the WBO welterweight champ

Jeff Horn was the WBO Inter-Continental welterweight champ

Lucas Matthysse was the WBA welterweight champ

[SouthpawRight]

El Chino disagree.

Jesse Vargas was the WBO welterweight champ

Jeff Horn was the WBO Inter-Continental welterweight champ

Lucas Matthysse was the WBA welterweight champ

yes beltholders in modern times that’s diluted with championships

Lower level contenders

[NarcosMaidana]

yes beltholders in modern times that’s diluted with championships

Lower level contenders

Still belt holders nonetheless, all those fighters mentioned were champion at the time Pacquiao faced them. You can't fault a fighter for picking easy opponents who are belt holders. Remember this famous slogan, "fight smarter, not harder". Does this only applies to certain fighters?

[NarcosMaidana]

yes beltholders in modern times that’s diluted with championships

Lower level contenders

Jesse Vargas WBO welterweight champ - 2016 (Who should have Pacquiao fought)?

Jeff Horn WBO Inter-Continental welterweight champ - 2017 (Who should have Pacquiao fought)?

Lucas Matthysse WBA (Regular) welterweight champ - 2018 (Who should have Pacquiao fought)?