Let's take a trip down memory lane, how would Floyd Mayweather Jr. have fared against these fighters had he not retired in 2007?

[IronDanHamza]

the thread is about PEOPLE the listed people listed over and over again for the years 2008 and 2009, i give up totally, nothing more i can say, the end of it

Erm, no, it's not

The thread is about Floyd retiring in 2007, and how he would have fared against the "Top WW's at the time" (from the picture) which is a picture taken from 2007.

You've just changed it to 2008 and 2009 for no reason.

This is roughly now the 5th or 6th false narrative you've attempted to push in this thread It's comical.

[TheProudLunatic]

I wasn't much of a boxing fan in my teens so I didn't get a chance to see any of these fighters in their primes but how do you think Floyd Mayweather would have done against these other top welterweight at the time? Tapology says Mayweather retired in 2007 and then came back and fought Juan Manuel Marquez in 2009. I'm guessing that was a tuneup to shake off ring rust since Marquez was picked from the Lightweight division.

DtVf6Y2.jpg

May > them all
Margarito and Kermit being the easiest
Paul would have posed the more difficult of the bunch
SRL looked like a Smurf next to Tommy
May would have looked even shorter vs Paul.

[RuleOfTheSpear]

Floyd beats Cintron.
50-50 against pre-marg undefeated Cotto.
Loses to Paul
50-50 against BALCO Mosley
Loses to Margarito

Floyd avoided tall fighters who are aggressive after that split decision with Oscar.

[lizard_man]

Floyd beats all of them easily. Remember, cotto was in the audience scouting mayweather when he fought gatti. Arum was trying to make that fight but cotto team said they weren't ready yet.

[lizard_man]

Floyd beats Cintron.
50-50 against pre-marg undefeated Cotto.
Loses to Paul
50-50 against BALCO Mosley
Loses to Margarito

Floyd avoided tall fighters who are aggressive after that split decision with Oscar.

YDKSAB.

Cotto's own team said they weren't ready for floyd.

Paul Williams would look like a robot against floyd.

Mosley would be his toughest match but he still gets pieced up.

He would make Margarito look like the baldomir fight or even worse.

[elfag]

i dont agree

when floyd announced his retirement in june of 2008 the top 3 ranked WW's were cheato, cotto, mosley with paul williams also willing to fight there

https://boxrec.com/wiki/index.php/Th..._Ratings:_2008

they were the top 3 because he beat 2 of the old top 3 and became number 1 himself.

do you understand how this works?

[djtmal]

May > them all
Margarito and Kermit being the easiest
Paul would have posed the more difficult of the bunch
SRL looked like a Smurf next to Tommy
May would have looked even shorter vs Paul.

Yes he woulda shoulda coulda beat them all had he not been too scared to fight them

[TheProudLunatic]

Yes he woulda shoulda coulda beat them all had he not been too scared to fight them

May > Pac as well , coward !

[djtmal]

May > Pac as well , coward !

Lol. Yeah right he woulda shoulda coulda beat him in 2009 as well if he wasn't scared, on vacation, retired, or his hands wasn't hurtin'.

[TheProudLunatic]

Lol. Yeah right he woulda shoulda coulda beat him in 2009 as well if he wasn't scared, on vacation, retired, or his hands wasn't hurtin'.

Who said the following in a bltch assed tone of voice -

"A tablespoon worth of my blood without AT LEAST 14 days notice.....I feel faint just thinking about it ......"

Coward