Was Ryan Garcia robbed a win ?

[WillieWild114]

https://www.boxingscene.com/articles...12-ryan-garcia these punch stats show he out punched Romero 7/12 rounds why wasn’t he awarded the Win ?

[IceTrayDaGang]

dont ever put ryan in a main event again. all that talk leading up the fight and then fought scared. i dont think ryan threw any power shots in fear of getting countered.

[Smash]

the punch stats say they were both awful

[ELPacman]

Did he win? If you want to say both guys didn't throw enough, give it to the man who knocked the other man down and call it a day. Rollie actually fought like he wanted it just a tad bit more. Ryan was in there to survive. Nor did he look in anyway like his prior form. (ahem).

Ryan is proving more and more how much of a farce he's always been. He honestly thought he could come in overweight vs Haney + use PEDs and either nobody would talk about it or immediately sweep it under the rug. Meanwhile collecting a "W" against a "legit" opponent.

Since it didn't happen, he got called out on it and had to turn up clean as *** for this fight, he may of doubted himself. He no longer had a size advantage or strength advantage as he did against Haney and it probably played with him a bit that he's facing an equal level opponent that has legit power. Then being dropped solidified his fears and made him hesistant to engage thereafter.

[Mammoth]

Nope..........

[DeeMoney]

Remember, compubox is just a couple guys clicking a button to when they think a punch landed, and in no way does it indicate the accuracy or force of the punch itself. Its not amateurs where its just a point per punch landed.

That being written, lets actually look at the punchstats. In only two separate rounds, 5 and 7 respectively, did Garcia out land in power punches. If we look at total punches landed, there were four separate rounds (1, 5, 7, and 8) in which he had more than a single total landed advantage. Romero also had four rounds (2, 6, 11, and 12) in which he had more than a single punch advantage in total lands.

That leaves rounds 3, 4, 9, and 10 as being roughly even with the punchstats. In both 3 & 4 each fighter the same amount of power shots, and in each Garcia landed one more jab- so we give him those two. In each of rounds 9 and 10 Romero landed one more power shot, which in lieu of one fighter landing a preponderance of more punches seems to be fair, so we give him those.

Mix in the KD, and this lands it at 114-113 for Romero.

Like I wrote earlier, its not amateurs, so just landing the most touches doesnt win it for you. You need to cause some sort of damage. This can be done by landing a preponderance of shots, which compubox points to neither fighter doing, or you can land the better shots- which compubox cant show, but I think most agree that Rolly did.

[QueensburyRules]

- - Nobody care. Great natural talent with 2cents for brains.

[The Big Dunn]

You know it’s bad when the Compubox defense is used. Lol

[WillieWild114]

Remember, compubox is just a couple guys clicking a button to when they think a punch landed, and in no way does it indicate the accuracy or force of the punch itself. Its not amateurs where its just a point per punch landed.

That being written, lets actually look at the punchstats. In only two separate rounds, 5 and 7 respectively, did Garcia out land in power punches. If we look at total punches landed, there were four separate rounds (1, 5, 7, and 8) in which he had more than a single total landed advantage. Romero also had four rounds (2, 6, 11, and 12) in which he had more than a single punch advantage in total lands.

That leaves rounds 3, 4, 9, and 10 as being roughly even with the punchstats. In both 3 & 4 each fighter the same amount of power shots, and in each Garcia landed one more jab- so we give him those two. In each of rounds 9 and 10 Romero landed one more power shot, which in lieu of one fighter landing a preponderance of more punches seems to be fair, so we give him those.

Mix in the KD, and this lands it at 114-113 for Romero.

Like I wrote earlier, its not amateurs, so just landing the most touches doesnt win it for you. You need to cause some sort of damage. This can be done by landing a preponderance of shots, which compubox points to neither fighter doing, or you can land the better shots- which compubox cant show, but I think most agree that Rolly did.

If that’s the case Wilder vs Fury 1 was actually a draw ?

[billeau2]

Ryan did use the jab nicely. But I do not think he won.