Who had the better career at Welterweight: Pacquiao or Crawford?

[IronDanHamza]

Where is Spence now you seem to know so much about him.

When he gonna resurface. 2028 2029?

He could retire now and he'd still have a better resume and career than Thurman.

Thurman has done nothing of note for years His last ranked win was 2017. EIGHT YEARS AGO.

[djtmal]

He could retire now and he'd still have a better resume and career than Thurman.

Thurman has done nothing of note for years His last ranked win was 2017. EIGHT YEARS AGO.

Lol. Untruth Spence IS retired.

That hypejob couldn't live up to the hype

Meanwhile Thurman proved he was the best ww when he fought Manny, and now after a loss.

Write boxrec and tell them you was misinformed

[IronDanHamza]

Lol. Untruth Spence IS retired.

That hypejob couldn't live up to the hype

Meanwhile Thurman proved he was the best ww when he fought Manny, and now after a loss.

Write boxrec and tell them you was misinformed

Show me one post where I have citied Boxrec.

Your position is Thurman proved he was the best WW by LOSING to someone who wasn't in the Top 3 at WW at the time and then hasn't beaten a ranked WW since and hasn't beaten a ranked WW in 8 years? That makes sense

[TheProudLunatic]

Pac's Murderer's Row -
Clottey
Cotto Lite
DONE La Hoya
Shot AF Mararito
Baby Margarito
Alcherry
Vargas
Lucas
Almost Bumlevel
Super Shot Mosley
Timmeh 3x ( )
JMM 2x (life and mostly death)
HORN (CPGW)
Basic AF Ugas

Pac would have needed to beat someone like Sometime 10x to make that shlt look kinda respectable

[djtmal]

Show me one post where I have citied Boxrec.

Your position is Thurman proved he was the best WW by LOSING to someone who wasn't in the Top 3 at WW at the time and then hasn't beaten a ranked WW since and hasn't beaten a ranked WW in 8 years? That makes sense

I said Thurman was the best ww in the world at the time he fought Manny keep up

You saying it was Spence because you loyal to boxrec, but losing the way he did showed that he was a hypejob and your source boxrec was wrong

[djtmal]

Pac's Murderer's Row -

DONE La Hoya
Shot AF Mararito
Baby Margarito

Lol. Where do I start your boy Maskingagentweather's pops said that same Done La Hoya beat his son, and Maskingagentweather ducked Margarito altogether

[IronDanHamza]

I said Thurman was the best ww in the world at the time he fought Manny keep up

You saying it was Spence because you loyal to boxrec, but losing the way he did showed that he was a hypejob and your source boxrec was wrong

Where have I cited Boxrec at any point in this thread?

[TheProudLunatic]

Lol. Where do I start your boy Maskingagentweather's pops said that same Done La Hoya beat his son, and Maskingagentweather ducked Margarito altogether

Your God signed off on that contract
Only you Pac bois and haters cry about something that everyone agreed to.

Now, remind me, why do you refuse to vote in that would you or wouldn't you poll ?!?!?!?

[joseph5620]

Pacquiao and its not close.
Cotto, Clottey, Bradley 2-3X, and Thurman were all TOP 5 WWs when he defeated them.
Thurman is comparable to Spence. Maybe Clottey to Porter.
The rest are B or C level type of fighters

Edit: I was in a hurry when i posted that. Adding more context to this.

DLH and JMM were both great wins as well but this is more of a Top P4P wins. Nothing to compare for Crawford really.

Pacquaio had Mosley, Mathysse and Broner, while Crawford had Khan and Brook. These fighters were at the top 5 of their divisions (WW or lower) during their primes but clearly not the best anymore when they met Pacquaio and Crawford.

Pacquaio other top 10 wins like Vargas is equivalent to Crawford win over Benavides Jr. and Kava

Lower rated/level oppenents
Pacquaio had wins over Algeiri and Rios. (Also Horn)
Crawford had wins over Horn (Who got his rankings by the Pacquaio robbery). Horn achieved nothing after his fluke win against Pac.

Pacquaio losses in WW were against two ATGs Marquez and Floyd, and Ugas when Pac was 42 years old. All competitive fights. Horn and Bradley were both clear robberies.

Against past prime and lower rank fighters they are pretty similiar but Pacquaio had like 6-7 best wins (including Marquez and DLH) better than Crawford 2 best wins in WW.

Neither of those were better wins at 147 than Spence. Marquez was not better at 147 than Spence or as good. He was soundly beaten and dominated at 147 by Mayweather and Bradley. Delahoya was clearly finished as a fighter when he faced Pacquiao and fighting at 147 completely drained him at that stage. Spence was a far better win than either one