At 147-154, Prime for Prime, how would Floyd Mayweather Jr fair against these five Pro Boxers he beat in the past?

[gamesworn]

Mayweather wasn't in his prime either. They were not facing the best version of Mayweather for any of those fights so that goes both ways. Not just for his opponents.


Mosley knocked out a prime Margarito. Those are the facts and those are the only facts that can be used. You have no idea what was in Margarito's head so that's only your personal speculation. Nothing factual about it.

You said Mayweather didn't fight them because he wasn't sure he could beat them. Mayweather never said this and you have no idea what his thoughts were. Again that's your perspective that has no basis in anything factual. There are also other factors for why those fights happened when they did that you're leaving out to create the narrative that Mayweather ducked all of them. You don't have to use the word "scared" when you're implying it.

Was Mosley Prime against Mayweather? Answer is No.

Again you are missing point here. OP was asking Prime vs Prime. It doesnt matter Floyd was his prime or not

Yes i said that and it is my opinion. We are in forum after all. He did avoid them and its my opinion. It is shared by many, i'm sorry to say to you.

[gamesworn]

Not really Floyd was backing out of fights to duck. That was obvious

They are still delusional fanboys who can't accept this. Floyd tried his best to protect his brand/his zero. I understand why he did it, but that comes without criticism. You can't expect fans loving you for cherry picking fights.

[Roadblock]

They are still delusional fanboys who can't accept this. Floyd tried his best to protect his brand/his zero. I understand why he did it, but that comes without criticism. You can't expect fans loving you for cherry picking fights.

It could be said youre a delusional hater, and it wouldn't be hard to prove, its funny watching haters call fanboy while propping other proven haters, the delusion is not seeing whats real because what you see is heavily filtered through hate. people in general are fkd in the head and they dont know it.

[gamesworn]

It could be said youre a delusional hater, and it wouldn't be hard to prove, its funny watching haters call fanboy while propping other proven haters, the delusion is not seeing whats real because what you see is heavily filtered through hate. people in general are fkd in the head and they dont know it.

Thanks for proving my point for being a delusional Floy Fanboy yourself. Because i don't agree with your fantasy version of Floyd, i'm now a hater. LOL

[BodyBagz]

Was Mosley Prime against Mayweather? Answer is No.

Again you are missing point here. OP was asking Prime vs Prime. It doesnt matter Floyd was his prime or not

Yes i said that and it is my opinion. We are in forum after all. He did avoid them and its my opinion. It is shared by many, i'm sorry to say to you.

Mosley was coming off his biggest W, though.
Unfortunately (?), it's prize fighting.
May did not retire the wealthiest boxer in history due to avoiding guys.
Sometimes a fight has to be built up for maximum financial rewards.
He was the p4p king and face of boxing
Those accolades are not given out to just anyone.

His best was not WW
ATGs who were naturally bigger than May would most likely beat him, but ti won't be easy.
No one beats PBF.

[Roadblock]

Thanks for proving my point for being a delusional Floy Fanboy yourself. Because i don't agree with your fantasy version of Floyd, i'm now a hater. LOL

What exactly is my fantasy version, that is coming from me not from your imagination, lol your a hater because of the BS you write, as I said your delusional and dont even know it .

[Lance98]

Mosley, oscar and cotto will never beat floyd as floyd is just better than them. Pac in 2011 was a lot more defensively flawed and would have ran into floyd's punches more. Canelo made the same mistakes in the bivol fight, but canelo is now way bigger physically, so floyd would have to be even more defensive, but would still beat him.

[BodyBagz]

They are still delusional fanboys who can't accept this. Floyd tried his best to protect his brand/his zero. I understand why he did it, but that comes without criticism. You can't expect fans loving you for cherry picking fights.

After getting KTFO in his 12th fight, lets examine Pac's road to CW King -
Fights 15-40, farmers and food vendors (another KO L, though)
Some guy named Ledwaba was supposed to mean something.
Eh, let's give him the benefit of the doubt.

1 "maybe" name out of his 1st 40 fights !!!
And got KTFO 2x !!!!

PBF got out of his prerequisite "bum" phase after his 18th fight.

Pac is finally stepping up, now -
Pac beat Barrera (his 62nd fight)
Barrera is a great fighter, but, pretty much the opponent Pac craves.
Nothing fancy
There to be hit

After knocking JMM down 3x in the 1st rd, Pac escaped with a Draw

Some unknown bum

Erik 1.
As with Marco, but more so, he is the perfect Pac opponent.
There to be hit.
Pac manages to lose

Some unknown

Erik 1
Pac got him this time

Larios, Mehrios

Erik 3
2/3 for Pac

Some bum

And an unwanted Barrera rematch, nearly 5 years later....

JMM 2 (SD)

Some Diaz guy

Now we ease into Pac's so called HOF portion of his career -

Fight 53 ------->
The worst possible version of DLH.
A pure cash out fight.
A fan boi keeps saying how Pac beat the brakes off this version.
I keep telling that fan boi those brakes were defective AF.

Hatton, never anyone special
Had a crazed fan base, doe.

Cotto lite
Cotto was the champ, but Pac was the money man.
Would never fight Cotto without a clause.

A statue named Clottey

The worst possible version of Antonio The Caveman (for some bullshlt title )

Mosley
Both May and Pac caught him on his decline
However, May fought Mosley after he KO'd Margarito

JMM 3 (MD)

Timmy 1 (Pure robbery L)

JMM 4 (NiteNite)

RIOS (AKA Baby Margarito )
Timmy 2
ALGIERI*
May (obvious L)
Timmy 3
VARGAS
HORN (CPGW ! Pure robbery, doe)
LUCAS ( prefab "champ" )
BRONER
Keef Sometime Hurtman. Lopez did it better, even in a loss
and finally
Basic AF Ugas (L)

Ever wonder why Pac didn't give HORN a rematch ?
Pac claims Horn turned it down
Why in the FCK would a part time school teacher turn down a 2nd big payday ?!?
It makes no sense. And even if HORN lost a rematch, it could have led to a 3rd big pay check.
Timmy got 2
Erik got 2
Barrera got 1 4 years after the 1st
Wanted a 5th JMM fight
Wouldn't give HORN a 2nd $$$$$

Trainer: Horn Most Likely Would've Stopped Pacquiao in Rematch (doubtful )
https://www.boxingscene.com/trainer-...ematch--128921
No reason in Hell for Team HORN to turn down a rematch
NONE !

And there you have it.

May's resume >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >> >>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >> >>>>>>>> Pac's

[gamesworn]

It could be said youre a delusional hater, and it wouldn't be hard to prove, its funny watching haters call fanboy while propping other proven haters, the delusion is not seeing whats real because what you see is heavily filtered through hate. people in general are fkd in the head and they dont know it.

Did you even read my first post on this thread? I was fair and i even thinks Floyd can defeat Canelo and Cotto the same way he did before. Now as for Dela Hoya, Mosley and Pacquaio. These three are completely different fighters when they were primes. More explosive, more stamina and more confident going into the fight. They still have something to prove. Same can be said with Floyd, that is why i think these are 50-50 fights.

Nothing suggest there i hated Floyd. I'm only dissing his delusional fans like you thinking he can beat them all during their primes. Which again is a pure fantasy.

[gamesworn]

After getting KTFO in his 12th fight, lets examine Pac's road to CW King -
Fights 15-40, farmers and food vendors (another KO L, though)
Some guy named Ledwaba was supposed to mean something.
Eh, let's give him the benefit of the doubt.

1 "maybe" name out of his 1st 40 fights !!!
And got KTFO 2x !!!!

PBF got out of his prerequisite "bum" phase after his 18th fight.

Pac is finally stepping up, now -
Pac beat Barrera (his 62nd fight)
Barrera is a great fighter, but, pretty much the opponent Pac craves.
Nothing fancy
There to be hit

After knocking JMM down 3x in the 1st rd, Pac escaped with a Draw

Some unknown bum

Erik 1.
As with Marco, but more so, he is the perfect Pac opponent.
There to be hit.
Pac manages to lose

Some unknown

Erik 1
Pac got him this time

Larios, Mehrios

Erik 3
2/3 for Pac

Some bum

And an unwanted Barrera rematch, nearly 5 years later....

JMM 2 (SD)

Some Diaz guy

Now we ease into Pac's so called HOF portion of his career -

Fight 53 ------->
The worst possible version of DLH.
A pure cash out fight.
A fan boi keeps saying how Pac beat the brakes off this version.
I keep telling that fan boi those brakes were defective AF.

Hatton, never anyone special
Had a crazed fan base, doe.

Cotto lite
Cotto was the champ, but Pac was the money man.
Would never fight Cotto without a clause.

A statue named Clottey

The worst possible version of Antonio The Caveman (for some bullshlt title )

Mosley
Both May and Pac caught him on his decline
However, May fought Mosley after he KO'd Margarito

JMM 3 (MD)

Timmy 1 (Pure robbery L)

JMM 4 (NiteNite)

RIOS (AKA Baby Margarito )
Timmy 2
ALGIERI*
May (obvious L)
Timmy 3
VARGAS
HORN (CPGW ! Pure robbery, doe)
LUCAS ( prefab "champ" )
BRONER
Keef Sometime Hurtman. Lopez did it better, even in a loss
and finally
Basic AF Ugas (L)

Ever wonder why Pac didn't give HORN a rematch ?
Pac claims Horn turned it down
Why in the FCK would a part time school teacher turn down a 2nd big payday ?!?
It makes no sense. And even if HORN lost a rematch, it could have led to a 3rd big pay check.
Timmy got 2
Erik got 2
Barrera got 1 4 years after the 1st
Wanted a 5th JMM fight
Wouldn't give HORN a 2nd $$$$$

Trainer: Horn Most Likely Would've Stopped Pacquiao in Rematch (doubtful )
https://www.boxingscene.com/trainer-...ematch--128921
No reason in Hell for Team HORN to turn down a rematch
NONE !

And there you have it.

May's resume >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >> >>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >> >>>>>>>> Pac's

Don't turn this into Pac and May thread lol