Floyd best night vs Manny best night who wins

[-Kev-]

Pacquiao has shown flaws even on his best nights.

Mayweather on his best nights shows zero flaws.

Pacquiao, pre-Mayweather, on his worst nights got KO’ed 3 times and outboxed twice. Those fights were Marquez 2x, Morales, Singsurat, and Torrecampo.

Mayweather on his worst nights won 2 close decisions and 1 wide decision. Those fights were Castillo, Mosley and Maidana.

And in the only fight that matters in this discussion, an old Mayweather beat the younger Pacquiao by clear and decisive unanimous decision.

[GrandpaBernard]

Floyd has too many tools for manny

Manny is limited in comparison

[elfag]

Manny in his prime (2009-2011) would probably walk thru Floyd honestly. That's why Floyd avoided Pac during that time. Manny was a monster. Mayweather would outbox Pacquiao until he got caught. Manny in those days would most likely knock down, TKO, or KO Floyd. He had too much speed, threw crazy combos with blinding speed and concussive power, and never got tired. Floyd would definitely have gotten his bell rung by Manny.

Floyd would have to have been extremely strong, sharp and focused. He looked very sharp, fast, and strong against Victor Ortiz. He would have a great chance at beating Manny skillwise in those days, but I don't think Floyd's chin would hold up. Manny would ROCK and HURT Mayweather like no boxer has before and the punches wouldn't stop coming.

2011 pacquaio barely gets by marquez. one year later he gets slept.

2010 peak pacquaio according you, cant figure out how to penetrate a simple high guard by clottey. but he "walks thru" floyd who never been walked through in 19 years as a pro.


lmfao sure dude

[GrandpaBernard]

manny cant cut the ring off

a come forward opponent who cant cut the ring off isn’t getting the job done

[GrandpaBernard]

Without a size advantage it’d take someone special like Henry Armstrong Duran or Pernell to beat Floyd

[punchr]

2011 pacquaio barely gets by marquez. one year later he gets slept.

2010 peak pacquaio according you, cant figure out how to penetrate a simple high guard by clottey. but he "walks thru" floyd who never been walked through in 19 years as a pro.


lmfao sure dude

Floyd has always been a better boxer with more tools of course no one is arguing that... but when Manny beat Hatton, Cotto, Margarito, Mosley, Floyd wanted nothing to do with Manny. During that window Manny would have beaten Floyd. The fight in 2015 was bull****. Manny wasn't the same destructive fighter anymore. Even then Floyd couldn't do **** to him. Floyd didn't dominate Manny or kick his ass. He used clinching and spoiler skills to get a decision. True champs don't back down fights.

[Atypicalbrit]

Floyd but Pac has a better chance than he did in their actual fight when he was more past it than Floyd.

[BodyBagz]

The PBF that beat Corrales >>>>>>>>>>>>> The Pac that beat Marco

[BodyBagz]

2011 pacquaio barely gets by marquez. one year later he gets slept.

2010 peak pacquaio according you, cant figure out how to penetrate a simple high guard by clottey. but he "walks thru" floyd who never been walked through in 19 years as a pro.


lmfao sure dude

Pac bois are not known for having logic.
Pac let a part time school teacher bully and rob him

Imagine Maidana vs Pac

[hogey]

At both their best I would go Manny Pacquiao to win 60-40. I just think the speed, workrate and accuracy would have been too much even for Floyd’s superb defensive skills. Sad we will never get to see who was truly the better man, by the time they eventually fought both men were past their best and it proved very little historically.