BoxRec TOP 5 WWs is a joke

Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • MaFu MoFo
    Undisputed Champion
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Aug 2007
    • 2525
    • 103
    • 84
    • 9,206

    #1

    BoxRec TOP 5 WWs is a joke

    1 Floyd Mayweather Jr 1794 40(25)-0(0)-0

    2 Shane Mosley 1741 46(39)-5(0)-0

    3 Antonio Margarito 958 37(27)-6(1)-0

    4 Miguel Angel Cotto 909 34(27)-1(1)-0

    5 Andre Berto 837 25(19)-0(0)-0



    Since winning the WW Tittle in 2006, PBF has not fight a true WW, but all of the sudden after beating a lifetime featherweight, now he is the top WW?!?!?! What a ****ing joke!!! How people keep defending PBF's career since he beated JUDAH is amazing. Floyd is definitely NOT THE BEST WelterWeight out there.

    I agree that SSM should be over Cotto, but Maragrito at number 3 is a hell of a joke too. Cotto is not receiving the credit he deserves. You may argue on who got a better record as a WW between Cotto and SSM. SSM is the man to beat in the division right now. Too bad, PBF is scare to fight him.

    Berto is sitting there at number 5, which is probably the place he deserves to be, specially when Clottey lost to Cotto. The rest of the top 10 is arguable. Quintana is number 15, mainly due to his inactivity. Cintron and PW are considered a LMW, 3rd and 1st, respectively. Gomez at 11th and Judah at 12th is another bad joke.

    I wonder what would happen if Paul Williams decides to have another fight at 147lbs. How will he change the rankings? PW may face anybody and MUST be place at number 1 if you keep track of what they did with MayWeather. In PW case, there is no boxer at WW or LWW willing to fight him. Not even SSM, Cotto, and obviously PBF.
  • Shattered Jaw
    Undisputed Champion
    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
    • Apr 2009
    • 5131
    • 261
    • 141
    • 11,649

    #2
    Clottey would tear Berto a new one:

    Ratings should go:

    1)Mosely (joint 1st)
    1)Cotto (joint 1st)
    3)Williams
    4)Clottey
    5)Mayweather

    Comment

    • street bully
      Tua's daddy.
      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
      • Jan 2008
      • 25014
      • 696
      • 263
      • 35,118

      #3
      Its computer simulated based on a body of stats run through a computer. I think they have Hopkins as P4P number 1.

      Comment

      • Bhopreign
        Banned
        • Jun 2006
        • 11273
        • 419
        • 100
        • 12,036

        #4
        Their rankings are computer based.

        Comment

        • MANGLER
          Sex Tape Flop Artist
          Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
          • Feb 2008
          • 30142
          • 1,705
          • 2,355
          • 46,598

          #5
          Boxrec on the whole is a joke. Nobody takes that **** seriously.

          Comment

          • BattlingNelson
            Mod a Phukka
            Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
            • Mar 2008
            • 29839
            • 3,246
            • 3,190
            • 286,536

            #6
            Boxrec rankings are always a joke. They are computerized with a worse algorithm than that of IBO.

            fight news has the best independent rankings today. Ring Magazines rankings are su****iously biased towards GBP fighters and Boxingscene's own rankings has handled Mayweathers return quite awful.

            Comment

            • Bhopreign
              Banned
              • Jun 2006
              • 11273
              • 419
              • 100
              • 12,036

              #7
              In defense Floyd is the last Lineal champ, no welter fighting today other than Judah has held that throne.

              Comment

              • MaFu MoFo
                Undisputed Champion
                Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                • Aug 2007
                • 2525
                • 103
                • 84
                • 9,206

                #8
                BoxRec is like BCS to college football, a huge bad joke!


                Anyway, I agree Clottey should be considered number 4, Berto number 5, Margarito number 6... SSM bieng number 1, followed by Cotto and PBF (whomever 2nd, 3rd)

                Comment

                • Mersey
                  Dirt Nasty
                  Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                  • Sep 2008
                  • 9423
                  • 619
                  • 496
                  • 18,766

                  #9
                  Don't look at Boxrec rankings it's not worth it. They have Cotto number 35 P4P

                  Comment

                  • larry x
                    Banned
                    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                    • Apr 2009
                    • 10715
                    • 499
                    • 247
                    • 11,556

                    #10
                    who gives a **** what boxrec says??its a computerized system that changes every week..the last person to fight is usually always#1

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP