BoxRec TOP 5 WWs is a joke

[MaFu MoFo]

Floyd retired for health reasons for the good of the sport so he could come back fresher, stronger, better for crying out loud. Cotto has never won a title that wasnt vacated, speaks volumes.

Wasnt fighting the best? So if he fought the last two lineal champs he wasnt fighting the best? Which is it guy.

You seem to be one of those guys that if PBF said that the sky was falling, you will believe him. Why don't you mention us and enlight us with your vast knowledge by mentioning all those welterweight boxers that PBF has defeted since he won the linear tittle from Baldomir.


You are officially in the hot seat... (clock is ticking...)

[Bhopreign]

You seem to be one of those guys that if PBF said that the sky was falling, you will believe him. Why don't you mention us and enlight us with your vast knowledge by mentioning all those welterweight boxers that PBF has defeted since he won the linear tittle from Baldomir.


You are officially in the hot seat... (clock is ticking...)

Again he beat the last two lineal champs, name another of these welters that did so since you hold them with high esteem.

[JAB5239]

Wasnt fighting the best? So if he fought the last two lineal champs he wasnt fighting the best? Which is it guy.

Being lineal champ doesn't automatically make you the best fighter in the division. It only means you're following a succession that leads back to the first title holder. Baldomir was a bum who beat a front runner. Is Floyd beating them really bigger than it would have been to beat Cotto, Margs, or Williams then? I think not. All have proven they are better fighters than those two. Is Floyd beating JMM really bigger than beating Cotto, Margs, Mosley, Clottey? Nota chance. So how can you justify Floyd being ranked #1 at welterweight?

[JAB5239]

Again he beat the last two lineal champs, name another of these welters that did so since you hold them with high esteem.

Both Cotto and Clottey have beaten Judah, and Baldomir has become obscure since he was never that good to begin with.

Just face it, most of the top welterweights have and are facing each other except for Floyd. Sorry bro, but if you ain't fighting the best it makes no sense to be called the best.

[MaFu MoFo]

Again he beat the last two lineal champs, name another of these welters that did so since you hold them with high esteem.

Wrong answer... try again... clock is ticking.

[Bhopreign]

Being lineal champ doesn't automatically make you the best fighter in the division. It only means you're following a succession that leads back to the first title holder. Baldomir was a bum who beat a front runner. Is Floyd beating them really bigger than it would have been to beat Cotto, Margs, or Williams then? I think not. All have proven they are better fighters than those two. Is Floyd beating JMM really bigger than beating Cotto, Margs, Mosley, Clottey? Nota chance. So how can you justify Floyd being ranked #1 at welterweight?

However you try and spin it he beat the last two lineal champs, nobody else has been lineal at welter other than Judah and Baldomir fighting right now. Bricked up Marg is out of the equation. You will never give credit where its due. Its a good thing the whole of Iredell County dont feel the same way.

[Junito-Rulez]

1) Cotto
2) Mosley
3) Clottey
4) Mayweather
5) Margarito

[Bhopreign]

Both Cotto and Clottey have beaten Judah, and Baldomir has become obscure since he was never that good to begin with.

Just face it, most of the top welterweights have and are facing each other except for Floyd. Sorry bro, but if you ain't fighting the best it makes no sense to be called the best.

He's the best pound for pound right now, there is a difference. Who said he's trying to be the best welter, we dont fight for bragging rights.

[Bhopreign]

1) Cotto
2) Mosley
3) Clottey
4) Mayweather
5) Margarito

If you believe Marg was bricked up against Cotto then he shouldnt be ranked at all.

[MaFu MoFo]

Both Cotto and Clottey have beaten Judah, and Baldomir has become obscure since he was never that good to begin with.

Just face it, most of the top welterweights have and are facing each other except for Floyd. Sorry bro, but if you ain't fighting the best it makes no sense to be called the best.

Baldomir's place in history is incredibly pure chance. BACK IN 2006, Baldomir would had lost his belt to any of the top WWs, it happened against Floyd. But to mention a few, baldomir would had lost against SSM, Cotto, Margarito, Judah in a rematch, Collazo, Cintron, Paul Williams, and probably others such as Gomez, Quintana, Lujan. Baldomir is a guy with Acromegaly that got lucky against Judah, and faced an old and over-the-hill Gatti. He has lost 12 fights including last one against Bonsu. If I were a Floyd NutHugger, I would not mention his win against Baldomir since it is as worthless as the ones against ODLH, Hatton and JMM.

In other simpler words, the last significant win that PBF had was against Judah in 2006, the rest is just bull**** wins to keep his record unremarkble.